Tuesday, March 04, 2008

George Mason's Master Draft of the Bill of Rights

"On
September 12, 1787, Elbridge Gerry and George Mason proposed that a committee be appointed to prepare a bill of rights. This proposal was unanimously rejected by the State delegations, and in consequence both withheld their signatures from the new Constitution.

Mason's Objections to This Constitution of Government were "There is no Declaration of Rights, and the laws of the general government being paramount to the laws and constitution of the several States, the Declarations of Rights in the separate States are no security."

By the time the Constitution had been ratified by the necessary nine States, several had proposed amendments to be inserted in the body of the Constitution, but no proposal had been made for a declaration of rights. On June 25, 1788, the Virginia ratifying convention appointed a committee to prepare a bill of rights. Two days later, the committee reported a proposed
bill of rights, and additional amendments to be included in the Constitution.

The proposal by this committee was a nearly verbatim copy of a Master Draft that George Mason had sent to Gen. John Lamb of the Republican Committee in New York on June 9th, a copy of which remains among the Lamb Papers at the New York Historical Society.

The receipt of the Draft was acknowledged in a letter to Mason from Judge Robert Yates, June 21:


'Your letter of the 9th inst. directed to John Lamb, Esquire at New York Chairman of the Federal Republican Committee in that City enclosing your proposed Amendments to the new Constitution, has been by him transmitted to such of the Members of Our Convention, who are in sentiment with him. In consequence of this Communication a Committee has been appointed by the members in Opposition to the New System (of which they have appointed me their Chairman) with a special view to continue our correspondence on this necessary and important Subject.We are happy to find that your Sentiments with respect to the Amendments correspond so nearly with ours, and that they stand on the Broad Basis of securing the Rights and equally promoting the Happiness of every citizen in the Union.'

The provisions of the bill of rights proposed by the
New York ratifying convention were primarly drawn from Mason's Master Draft, though in differing order.

North Carolina proposed a bill of rights whose provisions were nearly identical to those of the Virginia convention. The proposals later tendered by the ratifying convention of Rhode Island were probably taken directly from the Master Draft.

The bill of rights proposed by James Madison to the Congress on
June 8, 1789 was a nearly verbatim copy of Virginia's proposal, which was a nearly verbatim copy of Mason's Master Draft. Elbridge Gerry probably had a copy of this Draft before him during the congressional debates on the amendments.

In preparing the Master Draft, Mason drew heavily from the Virginia Declaration of Rights which he had written 12 years earlier, and also borrowed provisions from the Declarations of Rights of Pennsylvania and Maryland, as well as the Virginia Constitution of which he was also author. A manuscript copy of the Master Draft in George Mason's handwriting is among the Mason Papers at the Library of Congress.

Amendments to the New Constitution of Government_______
That there be a Declaration or Bill of Rights, asserting and securing
from Encroachment, the Essential and Unalienable Rights of the People, in some such manner as the following. —

1. That all Freemen have certain essential inherent Rights, of which they cannot by any Compact, deprive or divest their Posterity; among which are the Enjoyment of Life and Liberty, with the means of acquiring, possessing and protecting Property, and pursuing and obtaining Happiness and Safety.

2. That all Power is naturally vested in, and consequently derived from the People; that Magistrates therefore are their Trustees and Agents, and at all Times amenable to them.

3. That Government ought to be instituted for the Common Benefit, Protection and Security of the People; and that whenever any Government shall be found inadequate or contrary to these purposes, a Majority of the Community hath an indubitable unalienable and indefeasible Right to reform, alter or abolish it, and to establish another, in such manner as shall be judged most conducive to the public Weal; and that the Doctrine of non-resistance against arbitrary Power and Oppression is absurd, slavish and destructive of the good and Happiness of Mankind.

4. That no man or Set of Men are entitled to exclusive or separate public Emoluments or privileges from the Community, but in Consideration of public Services; which not being descendable neither ought the Offices of Magistrate, Legislator or Judge, or any other public Office to be hereditary.

5. That the Legislative, Executive and Judicial powers of Government should be separate and distinct; and that the members of the Two first may be restrained from Oppression, by feeling and participating the public Burthens, they should, at fixed periods, be reduced to a private Station, return into the Mass of the people, and the vacancies be supplied by certain and regular Elections, in which all, or any part of the Former members to be eligible or ineligible, as the Rules of the Constitution of Government and the Laws shall direct.

6. That the Right of the People to participate in the Legislature is the best Security of Liberty, and the Foundation of all Free Governments; for this purpose Elections ought to be free and frequent; and all men having sufficient Evidence of permanent common Interest with, and Attachment to the Community, ought to have the Right of Suffrage: And no Aid, Charge, Tax or Fee can be set, rated or levied upon the People without their own Consent, or that of their Representatives so elected; nor can they be bound by any Law to which they have not in like manner assented for the Public Good.

7. That all power of suspending Laws, or the Execution of Laws by any Authority, without Consent of the Representatives of the People in the Legislature, is injurious to their Rights, and ought not to be exercised.

8. That in all capital or criminal Prosecutions, a man hath a right to demand the cause & nature of his Accusation, to be confronted with the Accusers and Witnesses, to call for Evidence and be admitted Counsel in his Favor, and to a fair and speedy Trial by an impartial Jury of his Vicinage, without whose unanimous Consent he cannot be found guilty, (except in the Government of the Land and Naval Forces in Time of actual war, Invasion or rebellion) nor can he be compelled to give Evidence against himself.

9. That no Freeman ought to be taken, imprisoned, or desseized of his Freehold, Liberties, privileges or Franchises, or outlawed or exiled, or in any manner destroyed, or deprived of his Life, Liberty or Property, but by the Law of the Land.

10. That every Freeman restrained of his Liberty is entitled to a remedy, to enquire into the Lawfulness thereof, and to remove the same if unlawful, and that such Remedy ought not to be denied or delayed.

11. That in Controversies respecting Property, and in Suits between Man and man, the ancient Trial by Jury of Facts, where they arise, is one of the greatest Securities to the Rights of a Free people, and ought to remain sacred and inviolable.

12. That every Freeman ought to find a certain Remedy, by recourse to the Laws, for all Injuries or wrongs he may receive in his person, property or Character: He ought to obtain Right and Justice freely, without sale, compleatly and without Denial, promptly and without Delay; and that all Establishments or regulations contravening these Rights are oppressive and unjust.

13. That excessive Bail ought not to be required, nor excessive Fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual Punishments inflicted.

14. That every Freeman has a Right to be secure from all unreasonable Searches and Seizures of his Person, his papers, and his property; all Warrants therefore to search suspected places, or to seize any Freeman, his Papers or property, without Information upon Oath (or Affirmation of a person religiously scrupulous of taking an Oath) of legal and sufficient Cause, are grievous and Oppressive; and all General Warrants to search suspected Places, or to apprehend any suspected Person, without specially naming or describing the Place or Person, are dangerous and ought not to be granted.

15. That the People have a Right peaceably to assemble together to consult for their common Good, or to instruct their Representatives, and that every Freeman has a right to petition or apply to the Legislature for redress of Grievances.

16. That the People have a right to Freedom of speech, and of writing and publishing their Sentiments; that the Freedom of the Press is one of the great Bulwarks of Liberty, and ought not to be violated.

17. That the People have a Right to keep and to bear Arms; that a well regulated Militia, composed of the Body of the People, trained to arms, is the proper, natural, and safe Defence of a free State; that Standing Armies in Time of Peace are dangerous to Liberty, and therefore ought to be avoided as far as the Circumstances and Protection of the Community will admit; and that in all Cases, the military should be under strict Subordination to, and governed by the Civil Power.

18. That no Soldier in Time of Peace ought to be quartered in any House without the Consent of the Owner; and in Time of War, only by the civil Magistrate in such manner as the Laws direct.

19. That any Person religiously scrupulous of bearing Arms ought to be exempted upon payment of an Equivalent to employ another to bear Arms in his stead.

20. That Religion or the Duty which we owe to our Creator, and the manner of discharging it, can be directed only by Reason and Conviction, not by Force or violence, and therefore all men have an equal, natural, and unalienable Right to the free Exercise of Religion according to the Dictates of Conscience, and that no particular religious Sect or Society of Christians ought to be favored or established by Law in preference to others.
____________


That each State in the Union shall retain its Sovereignty, Freedom and Independence, and every Power, Jurisdiction and Right which is not by this Constitution expressly delegated to the Congress of the United States.

That there shall be one Representative for every Thirty Thousand Persons according to the Enumeration or Census mentioned in the Constitution until the whole Number of representatives amounts to Two Hundred.

That Congress shall not exercise the Powers respecting the regulation of Elections, vested in them by the Fourth Section of the First Article of the Constitution, but in Cases when a State neglects or refuses to make the Regulations therein mentioned, or shall make Regulations subversive of the Rights of the People to a free and equal Representation in Congress agreeably to the Constitution, or shall be prevented from making Elections by Invasion or Rebellion; and in any of these Cases, such Powers shall be exercised by the Congress only until the Cause be removed.

That the Congress do not lay direct Taxes, nor Excises upon any Articles of the growth, or manufactured from the growth of any of the American States, but when the Monies arising from the Duties on Imports are insufficient for the public Exigencies; nor then until the Congress shall have first made a Requisition upon the States, to assess, levy and pay their respective Proportions of such requisitions according to the Enumeration or Census fixed in the Constitution, in such Way and Manner as the Legislature of the State shall judge best; and if any State shall neglect or refuse to pay its proportion pursuant to such Requisition, then Congress may assess and levy such States' proportion, together with Interest thereon, at the Rate of Six per Centum per Annum, from the Time of Payment prescribed in such requisition.

That the Members of the Senate and House of Representatives shall be ineligible to, and incapable of holding any Office under the Authority of the United States, during the Time for which they shall respectively be elected.

* That there shall be a constitutional responsible Council, to assist in the Administration of Government, with the Power of chusing out of their own Body, a President, who in the case of the Death, Resignation, or Disability of the President of the United States, shall act, pro tempore, as Vice President instead of a Vice President elected in the Manner prescribed by the Constitution; and that the Power of making Treaties, appointing Ambassadors, other public Ministers or Consuls, Judges of the Supreme Courts, and all other Officers of the United States, whose appointments are not otherwise provided for by the Constitution, and which shall be established by Law, be vested in the President of the United States with the Assistance of the Council so to be appointed. But all Treaties so made or entered into, shall be subject to the Revision of the Senate and House of Representatives for their Ratification. And no Commercial Treaty shall be ratified without the Consent of Two-Thirds of the members present in both Houses; nor shall any Treaty ceding, contracting, restraining or suspending the Territorial Rights or Claims of the United States, or any of them, or their or any of their Rights or Claims to fishing in the American Seas, or navigating the American Rivers be ratified without the Consent of Three-Fourths of the whole number of the members of both Houses.

No Navigation Law, or Law for regulating Commerce, shall be passed without the Consent of Two-Thirds of the Members present in both Houses.

No Standing Army or Regular Troops shall be raised or kept up in Time of Peace without the Consent of Two-Thirds of the members of both Houses.

Neither the President, nor Vice President of the United States, nor any member of the Council, shall command the Army or Navy of the United States in person, without the Consent of Two-Thirds of the members of both Houses.

No Soldier shall be enlisted for a longer Term than four Years, except in Time of War, and then for no longer Term than the Continuance of the War.

No Mutiny Act shall be passed for any longer Term than Two years.

The President of the United States, or any other Officer acting under the Authority of the United States shall, upon Impeachment, be suspended from the Exercise of his Office during his Trial.
The Judges of the Federal Court shall be incapable of holding any other Office, or of receiving the Profits of any other Office or Emolument under the United States or any of them.

* This article not yet finally agreed upon by the Committee appointed to prepare the amendments. _____

[NOTE: The footnote refers to the committee in the Republican Society tasked with preparing amendments to present to the Virginia ratifying convention, as this Master Draft had been written at least 2 weeks before the Virginia convention appointed a committee to prepare amendments.]




Sunday, February 10, 2008

Christian Reconstructionism


By John Sugg, an editor of Creative Loafing in an article covering a convention in Toccoa, Georgia of the Reconstructionist religious movement, a movement holding the belief that the world must come under Christian "dominion", as they define it, before the return of Christ for His millenial reign. This article outlines the ideas and actions reconstructionists propose to implement to facilitate that return.

"Traditional Christian theology teaches that history will muddle along until Jesus’ Second Coming. That teaching is tough to turn into a political movement. Reconstruc­tionists preach that the nation and the world must come under Christian “dom­in­ion” (as they define it) before Christ’s return – a wonderful theology to promote global conquest. At a convention in Toccoa, Georgia, Gary North, a leader in Reconstructionism re-iterated the beliefs of the Reconstructionists:

• The First Amendment was intended to keep the federal government from imposing a national religion, but states should be free to foster a religious creed. (Several states did that during the colonial period and the nation’s early days, a model the Reconstructionists want to emulate.)

• The Founding Fathers intended to protect only the liberties of the established ultra-conservative denominations of that time. Expanding the list to include “liberal” Protestant denominations, much less Catholics, Jews and (gasp!) atheists, is a corruption of the Founders’ intent.

• Six-day, “young earth” creationism is the only acceptable doctrine for Christians. Even “intelligent design” or “old earth” creationism are compromises with evil secularism.

• Public education is satanic and must be destroyed.

Education earned the most vitriol at the conference. Effusing that the Reli­gi­ous Right has captured politics and much of the media, North proclaimed: “The only thing they (secularists) have still got a grip on is the university system.” Academic doctorates, he contended, are a conspiracy fomented by the Rocke­feller family. All academic programs (except, he said, engineering) are now dominated by secularists and Darwinists.

“Marxists in the English departments!” he ranted. “Close every public school in America!”

Among North’s most quoted writings was this ditty from 1982: “[W]e must use the doctrine of religious liberty to gain independence for Christian schools until we train up a generation…which...(will) deny religious liberty to the enemies of God.” quote edited for clarification.

Titus followed that party line when he proclaimed that the First Amendment is limited to guaranteeing “the right to criticize the government,” but “free expression is not in the Constitution.” When I asked him if blasphemy – castigating religion – was protected, he shook his head.

Like North, Titus sees public education as decidedly satanic. Also, welfare. He contended the Founding Fathers – and Americans today – owe their “first duties to God. It’s not just worship. It’s education…welfare to the poor. Welfare belongs exclusively to God. Why do schools fail? They’re trying to do the business of God. Medicaid goes. Edu­cation goes. The church gets back to doing what it should do.”

And what should the church be doing? According to these self-appointed arbiters of God’s will, running our lives. And stoning those who disagree.

At the Toccoa conference, DeMar org­anized several debates – and he commendably invited articulate opponents of his creed.

One was Ed Buckner, a retired Geor­gia State University professor, unabash­ed atheist and a member of the Atlanta Freethought Society. He debated Bill Federer, who makes a living trying to prove America’s founders intended this to be a Christian nation.

Buckner offered to concede the debate if Federer could disprove any one of four points: Americans don’t agree on religion, human judgment is imperfect, religious truth can’t be determined by votes or force and freedom is worth protecting. Federer ran from the challenge, and instead offered a litany of historic quotes showing that most of America’s founders believed in God.

Federer never got the point that if, as he argued, government should endorse his faith today, tomorrow officials might decide to ban his beliefs.

The other debate featured University of Georgia biologist Mark Farmer versus Australian “young earth” creationist Carl Wieland. Farmer, religious himself, tried to explain that no evidence had ever damaged evolutionary theory – at best, creationists point to gaps in knowledge.

“Yes, we don’t know the answers to everything,” Farmer told me. “That’s what science is all about, finding answers.”

It would be easy to dismiss the Reconstructionists as the lunatic fringe, no more worrisome than the remnants of the Prohibition Party. But, in fact, they have rather extraordinary entrée and influence with top-tier Religious Right leaders and institutions.

James Dobson’s Focus on the Family is now selling DeMar’s book, America’s Christian Heritage. Dobson himself has a warm relationship with many in the movement, and he has admitted voting for Reconstructionist presidential candidate Howard Phillips in 1996.

TV preacher Robertson has mentioned reading North’s writings, and he has hired Reconstructionists as professors at Regent University. Jerry Falwell em­ploys Reconstructionists to teach at Liberty Uni­­versity. Roger Schultz, the chair of Liberty’s History Department, writes regularly for Faith for all of Life, the leading Reconstructionist journal.

Southern Baptist Bruce N. Shortt is aggressively pushing his denomination to officially repudiate public education and call on Southern Baptists to withdraw their children from public schools. Shortt’s vicious book, The Harsh Truth about Public Schools, was published by the Reconstructionist Chalcedon Foun­da­tion.

There are some theological differences between the Religious Right’s generals and the Reconstructionists., but, in short, Dobson, Robertson, Falwell and the Southern Baptist Convention (the nation’s largest Protestant denomination) may not agree with everything the Re­constructionists advocate, but they sure don’t seem to mind hanging out with this openly theocratic, anti-democratic crowd.

It’s enough for Americans who be­lieve in personal freedom and religious liberty to get worried about – before the first stones start flying."

John Sugg is senior editor of Creative Loafing Newspapers, which owns alternative newsweeklies in Atlanta, Charlotte, Tampa and Sarasota. He was the recipient of the 2005 Society of Professional Journalists “Green Eyeshade” award for serious commentary, and he has won more than 30 other significant awards.

Thursday, January 17, 2008



Jefferson's Statute for Religious Freedom


In 1786 on January 16, the Virginia Assembly passed Thomas Jefferson's Statute for Religious Freedom. Jefferson had tried to get it passed once, but failed.

In the fall of 1785, Jefferson was Ambassador to France, and James Madison propelled the bill to passage in response to a bill by Patrick Henry that would have forced Virginians to support Christian ministers with their tax dollars.


The Jefferson bill initiated societal change away from established churches toward religious freedom and became the model for the first amendment religion clauses, creating the the trend that would sweep throughout the states, disestablishing all state religions, until finally in 1833, when the last one, Massachusetts, after almost two hundred years, acquiesed, they all were gone.



The full text of Jefferson's statute:



VIRGINIA STATUTE FOR RELIGIOUS FREEDOM

[Sec. 1] Whereas Almighty God hath created the mind free; that all attempts to influence it by temporal punishments or burthens, or by civil incapacitations, tend only to beget habits of hypocrisy and meanness, and are a departure from the plan of the Holy author of our religion, who being Lord both of body and mind, yet chose not to propagate it by coercions on either, as it was in his Almighty power to do; that the impious presumption of legislators and rulers, civil as well as ecclesiastical, who being themselves but fallible and uninspired men, have assumed dominion over the faith of others, setting up their own opinions and modes of thinking as the only true and infallible, and as such endeavouring to impose them on others, hath established and maintained false religions over the greatest part of the world, and through all time; that to compel a man to furnish contributions of money for the propagation of opinions which he disbelieves, is sinful and tyrannical; that even the forcing him to support this or that teacher of his own religious persuasion, is depriving him of the comfortable liberty of giving his contributions to the particular pastor, whose morals he would make his pattern, and whose powers he feels most persuasive to righteousness, and is withdrawing from the ministry those temporary rewards, which proceeding from an approbation of their personal conduct, are an additional incitement to earnest and unremitting labours for the instruction of mankind; that our civil rights have no dependence on our religious opinions, any more than our opinions in physics or geometry; that therefore the proscribing any citizen as unworthy the public confidence by laying upon him an incapacity of being called to offices of trust and emolument, unless he profess or renounce this or that religious opinion, is depriving him injuriously of those privileges and advantages to which in common with his fellow-citizens he has a natural right; that it tends only to corrupt the principles of that religion it is meant to encourage, by bribing with a monopoly of worldly honours and emoluments, those who will externally profess and conform to it; that though indeed these are criminal who do not withstand such temptation, yet neither are those innocent who lay the bait in their way; that to suffer the civil magistrate to intrude his powers into the field of opinion, and to restrain the profession or propagation of principles on supposition of their ill tendency, is a dangerous fallacy, which at once destroys all religious liberty, because he being of course judge of that tendency will make his opinions the rule of judgment, and approve or condemn the sentiments of others only as they shall square with or differ from his own; that it is time enough for the rightful purposes of civil government, for its officers to interfere when principles break out into overt acts against peace and good order; and finally, that truth is great and will prevail if left to herself, that she is the proper and sufficient antagonist to error, and has nothing to fear from the conflict, unless by human interposition disarmed of her natural weapons, free argument and debate, errors ceasing to be dangerous when it is permitted freely to contradict them:

[Sec. 2] Be it enacted by the General Assembly, That no man shall be compelled to frequent or support any religious worship, place, or ministry whatsoever, nor shall be enforced, restrained, molested, or burthened in his body or goods, nor shall otherwise suffer on account of his religious opinions or belief; but that all men shall be free to profess, and by argument to maintain, their opinion in matters of religion, and that the same shall in no wise diminish enlarge, or affect their civil capacities.
[Sec. 3] And though we well know that this assembly elected by the people for the ordinary purposes of legislation only, have no power to restrain the acts of succeeding assemblies, constituted with powers equal to our own, and that therefore to declare this act to be irrevocable would be of no effect in law; yet we are free to declare, and do declare, that the rights hereby asserted are of the natural rights of mankind, and that if any act shall be hereafter passed to repeal the present, or to narrow its operation, such act shall be an infringement of natural right.

Monday, January 14, 2008

CEO Pay: Money for Nothing? By Dean Baker
Monday 14 January 2008


One of the standard yearend rituals is to assess the stock market's performance for the year. Many people noted the Dow Jones index rose a respectable 7.5 percent in 2007. Before anyone celebrates this modest achievement, it is important to remember the Dow includes just 30 blue chip stocks. The much broader S&P 500 index rose by just 3.5 percent, slightly less than the rate of inflation in 2007. In other words, the real return for most stockholders was roughly equal to what their stock paid out in dividends, not a terribly good story.

In fact, poor stock returns are not a new phenomenon. If we go back ten years, we find the S&P 500 has risen by a cumulative total of 52.6 percent from December 1997 to December 2007. After adjusting for inflation, the increase was 17.3 percent, which translates into real growth of just 1.6 percent a year. Add in a dividend yield of approximately the same size, and we get that the average real return on stocks over the last decade has been 3.2 percent, a bit lower than the yield that was available on inflation-indexed government bonds ten years ago.

This is rather striking. It is unlikely many people invested in stock for the sort of return that is typically associated with government bonds, which are much less risky. At least for the last decade, stockholders have not been rewarded for taking this risk.

This brings us to the topic of CEO pay. We saw an explosion in CEO pay that began in the eighties and has continued into the current decade. While the ratio of the pay of CEOs to an average worker had been around 30 to 1 in the sixties and seventies, by the end of the eighties it stood at more than 70 to 1. It crossed 100 to 1 in the early nineties. The ratio has been perched between 200 to 1 and 300 to 1 since the late nineties, with CEOs at major companies routinely pulling down pay packages in the tens of millions, and running into the hundreds of millions in good years.

This explosion of pay at the top was justified, by many economists, based on the returns CEOs produced for shareholders. The argument was that even these incredibly high salaries still were just a small fraction of the value the CEOs generated, so their pay was money well spent. These exorbitant salaries gave the CEOs the necessary incentive to produce extraordinary returns.

While this argument may never have been terribly compelling (it would have been hard to keep a company's stock prices from rising in the nineties bubble), it clearly is not true today. The typical CEO is not producing great returns for shareholders. The average return is weak, and in many cases shareholders are incurring loses due to CEO mismanagement. Even in the disaster stories, the CEOs still seem to get extraordinary pay packages.

The poster child for this new trend is Robert Nardelli. In five years as CEO at Home Depot, he lost shareholders 40 percent of the stock's value, more than $25 billion. When he was eventually pushed out the door, he walked away with a compensation package worth more than $200 million. Call it "pay for nonperformance."

In the fifties and sixties, it was common to think of corporations as bodies that served a variety of stakeholders. In addition to shareholders, corporations were also seen as having responsibilities to their workers, to the communities in which they were located, to their consumers, and even the larger society. This diverse group of stakeholders sometimes meant that a company should sacrifice short-term profit maximization in order to meet some broader goal.

In the eighties, we got the shareholder revolution, which said corporate management should focus simply on maximizing shareholder value. If this meant mass layoffs of workers or abandoning communities where a company had deep roots, so be it.

As a result of the shareholder revolution, the range of constituencies the corporation was expected to serve was drastically narrowed. Concerns for workers, communities, and the larger society were jettisoned, with shareholder value being the only true concern for the corporation and the CEOs that run them. This single-minded concern for profit maximization and shareholder value was supposed to be best for society in the long run.

It turns out, the range of constituencies has been narrowed even further than we realized. With recent evidence on returns, it doesn't look like shareholders fit in the equation anymore. At least the CEOs are still doing well.

Dean Baker is the co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR). He is the author of The Conservative Nanny State: How the Wealthy Use the Government to Stay Rich and Get Richer (www.conservativenannystate.org).
More Attempts at Chipping Away...

 
On Monday 14 January 2008 House Resolution 888, sponsored by Congressman Randy Forbes...has in it a proclamation that states, "Whereas in 1777, Congress, facing a National shortage of 'Bibles for our schools, and families, and for the public worship of God in our churches,' announced that they 'desired to have a Bible printed under their care & by their encouragement' and therefore ordered 20,000 copies of the Bible to be imported 'into the different ports of the States of the Union'."

'...The resolution, which was first reported on Talk2Action by Chris Rodda, author of the book "Liars for Jesus: The Religious Right's Alternate Version of American History," and the senior research director at the government watchdog organization The Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF), was introduced by Forbes on December 18, the last day Congress was in session before lawmakers left for their winter break.



Rodda first discovered the resolution after researching Congress's legislative web site for work she has been doing on behalf of MRFF.


"House Resolution 888," said Mikey Weinstein, founder and president of MRFF, a nonprofit watchdog group which aims a close eye on the military to ensure it abides by the law mandating the separation between church and state, "...is a myriad of tortured and deliberate historical fictions, fused by it's Congressional-member drafters into a ....Christian exceptionalism and triumphalism, and clearly illuminate its private sector and legislative sponsors' desire to spare absolutely no effort to complete the transformation of our country into "The United Christian States of America."

Weinstein was a former White House counsel during the Reagan administration, former general counsel to Texas billionaire and two-time presidential candidate H. Ross Perot and a former Air Force Judge Advocate General.
In House Resolution 888, Rodda says Forbes has grossly misrepresented and distorted the historical record he references in the 75 proclamation of H. Res 888.

"This resolution, which purports to promote 'education on America's history of religious faith,' is packed with the same American history errors found on the Christian nationalist websites, and in the books of pseudo-historians like David Barton," Rodda wrote on the Talk2Action web site.
"It lists a total of seventy-five 'Whereas,' leading up to four resolves, the third of which is particularly disturbing - that the U.S. House of Representatives 'rejects, in the strongest possible terms, any effort to remove, obscure, or purposely omit such history from our Nation's public buildings and educational resources,' which is a considerable travesty considering that most of the 'history' this resolve aims to promote in our public buildings and schools IS NOT REAL!"

One example, says Rodda, is the proclamation by Forbes that "Congress pursued a plan to print a Bible that would be 'a neat edition of the Holy Scriptures for the use of schools' and therefore approved the production of the first English language Bible printed in America that contained the congressional endorsement that the United States in Congress assembled ... recommend this edition of the Bible to the inhabitants of the United States."

"Congress did not 'pursue a plan to print' this Bible, as Mr. Forbes claims, nor did they 'approve the production,' Rodda said.
"Robert Aitken was already printing his Bibles as of January 21, 1781 when he petitioned Congress. All they did was grant one of several requests made by Aitken by having their chaplains examine his work, and allowing him to publish their resolution stating that, based on the chaplains' report, they were satisfied that his edition was accurate. The words 'a neat edition of the Holy Scriptures for the use of schools' are taken from a letter written by Aitken, not the resolution of Congress."

Forbes did not respond to a request for comment.

Congressman Forbes is using the resolution to circumvent the The Establishment Clause of the First Amendment of the Bill of Rights which says Congress shall make no law regarding an establishment of religion.

Forbes has also introduced two bills, one that would protect the rights of lawmakers to express "their religious beliefs through public prayer by removing all establishment clause cases involving prayer by public officials from federal court jurisdiction to the jurisdiction of state courts." The other legislation Forbes introduced "would bar judges from awarding legal fees to groups that sue municipalities for violating the Constitution's ban on government establishment of religion."

Forbes and two other congressmen held up passage of the defense budget for several weeks over the removal of a military chaplain prayer provision that sought to authorize chaplains to pray in the name of Jesus Christ at military invocations.

The guidelines, rewritten in 2005 after Weinstein exposed the religious intolerance and anti-Semitism carried out by fundamentalist officers, staff and cadets at the AIr Force Academy in Colorado Springs against those at the academy who refused to accept Jesus Christ as "their personal Lord and savior". Weinstein wrote about the issue in
his book "With God On Our Side: One Man's War Against An Evangelical Coup in America's Military."


Forbes, along with congressmen Todd Akin of Missouri, and Walter Jones of North Carolina, threatened to block passage of the National Defense Authorization Act of 2007 unless Congress passed the bill with their proposal intact and the proposal was eventually withdrawn, and in exchange, Forbes and his colleagues were handed a deal abrogating the Air Force and Navy guidelines on religious expression, essentially giving evangelical military chaplains a loophole to proselytize, an issue Weinstein says he intends to fight in court.

Last year, MRFF filed a lawsuit in federal court against Secretary of Defense Robert Gates and US Army Maj. Freddy Welborn, on behalf of an Army soldier stationed in Iraq. The complaint, filed in US District Court in Kansas City, alleges Jeremy Hall, an Army specialist currently on active duty in Combat Operations Base Speicher, Iraq, had his First Amendment rights violated when Welborn threatened to retaliate against Hall and block his reenlistment in the Army because of Hall's atheist beliefs."
Church historian Gary Dorrian has a commentary about Mitt Romney's speech -- and the political ripples since -- over at the web site of Union Theological Seminary.

"When Kennedy ran for the presidency in 1960, the Catholic Church was still officially opposed to religious freedom. Kennedy's adviser on the church and state issue was American Jesuit theologian John Courtney Murray, who approved the Houston speech a few hours before it was delivered. But Murray's views on this subject, while important to Kennedy's campaign, were contrary to church doctrine. In 1955 the Vatican had silenced Murray on this subject, forbidding him to write about religious freedom. In 1965 Murray's view prevailed at Vatican Council II, as the church changed its teaching on religious freedom. Had Kennedy allowed himself to be drawn into a discussion of Catholic doctrine in 1960, it would not have gone well.

Romney keenly understands that the same thing is true in his case, only more so; thus he ruled out option two. The option that he took was the generic one of devoting an entire speech to the issue while saying as little as possible. He stood up for his Mormon faith without saying what it was. With only slight tweaks he gave a generic religion-in-public speech that any Republican or Democratic candidate might have delivered. The only section with an edge was his shot at "the religion of secularism."

In Romney's telling, the difference between the 1960s and today on this subject is that secularism has grown powerful. Secular types are trying to strip the public sphere of "any acknowledgment of God," he warns. However, that is far from the whole story. In 1967 George Romney could run for president without having to defend or even mention his Mormon religion. Mitt Romney surely realizes that something has gone wrong in American politics and culture since then, even as he does a delicate dance with the very movement that changed the rules and made his theology the issue. If Romney thinks he has put that issue to rest, he has a rude surprise coming."

Saturday, January 12, 2008


What Is the Purpose of Life on Earth?

Man was created in the image of God and placed on this earth to experience existence between the pre-mortal life and post-mortal life as a part of the evolution of his eternal being. Mortal life is a test to see if we'll obey, not only the lower laws to which mortals are born, but a test to see if we'll obey, as they are learned, the higher, eternal laws, which God, Himself, obeys. Only by obeying both the lower and the higher laws can we return to Him in the postmortal life. The mission of each person born in mortality is the search for the way to return to life in the eternal worlds from whence we came, a process of continuous evolution in always becoming. Accomplishing that goal can only be achieved by learning that we were begotten by God, the Father of our spirits, by learning the laws which govern that process of return and by adhering to them once they are known. There is no other way.

In the process of learning and applying those laws in this sojourn on earth, one may fall short of knowledge and will, and have to take a step back, re-assess the situation to once again proceed forward. Only by faith in God that He will provide guidance for us to recover and continue to proceed forward can we each one evolve to become that which He desires for us and we desire for ourselves and for all who have lived in mortality, now live, and will come to live. We agreed with this plan and we voted for it by acclamation as intelligent entities in our pre-mortal life. We agreed to move to this earth, acquire a mortal body, and live the laws we obeyed in the previous plane of our existance. We agreed that we would allow a veil to fall between us and our previous life, so that we could live by faith for humility's sake. For it is only when we are humble are we able to learn.

President Spencer W. Kimball (1895-1995) tells it this way:

“Our first parents, Adam and Eve, disobeyed God. By eating the forbidden fruit, they became mortal. Consequently, they and all of their descendants became subject to both mortal and spiritual death (mortal death, the separation of body and spirit; and spiritual death, the separation of the spirit from the presence of God and death as pertaining to the things of the spirit).

“In order for Adam to regain his original state (to be in the presence of God), an atonement for this disobedience was necessary. In God’s divine plan, provision was made for a redeemer to break the bonds of death and, through the resurrection, make possible the reunion of the spirits and bodies of all persons who had dwelt on earth. “Jesus of Nazareth was the one who, before the world was created, was chosen to come to earth to perform this service, to conquer mortal death” (“The True Way of Life and Salvation,” Ensign, May 1978, 6).

Thursday, January 10, 2008


No Jobs for the New Economy (or the Old)

08 January 2008

By PAUL CRAIG ROBERTS former Assistant Secretary of the Treasury in Reagan Administration

December did not bring Americans any jobs. To the contrary, the private sector lost 13,000 jobs from the previous month.

If December is a harbinger of the new year, it is going to be a bad one. The past year, hailed by Republican propagandists and "free trade" economists as proof of globalism's benefit to Americans, was dismal. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics' nonfarm payroll data, the US "super economy" created a miserable 1,054,000 net new jobs during 2007.

This is not enough to keep up with population growth--even at the rate discouraged Americans, unable to find jobs, are dropping out of the work force--thus the rise in the unemployment rate to 5%.

During the past year, US goods producing industries, continuing a long trend, lost 374,000 jobs.

But making things was the "old economy." The "new economy" provides services. Last year 1,428,000 private sector service jobs were created.

Are the "free trade" propagandists correct that these service jobs, which are our future, are high-end jobs in research and development, innovation, venture capitalism, information technology, high finance, and science and engineering where the US allegedly has such a shortage of scientists and engineers that it must import them from abroad on work visas?

Not according to the official job statistics.

What occupations provided the 1.4 million service jobs in 2007?

Waitresses and bartenders accounted for 304,200, or 21% of the new service jobs last year and 29% of the net new jobs.

Health care and social assistance accounted for 478,400, or 33% of the new service jobs and 45% of the net new jobs. Ambulatory health care and hospitals accounted for the lion's share of these jobs.

Professional and business services accounted for 314,000, or 22% of the new service jobs and 30% of the net new jobs.

Are these professional and business service jobs the high-end jobs of which "free traders" speak? Decide for yourself.

Services to buildings and dwellings account for 53,600 of the jobs. Accounting and bookkeeping services account for 60,500 of the jobs. Architectural and engineering services account for 54,700 of the jobs. Computer systems design and related services account for 70,400 of the jobs. Management consultants account for 88,400 of the jobs.

There were more jobs for hospital orderlies than for architects and engineers. Waitresses and bartenders accounted for as many of last year's new jobs as the entirety of professional and business services.

Wholesale and retail trade, transportation, and utilities accounted for 181,000 of 2007's new jobs.

Where are the rest of the new jobs? There are a few scattered among arts, entertainment, and recreation, repair and maintenance, personal and laundry services, and membership associations and organizations.

That's it.

Keep in mind that the loss of 374,000 goods producing jobs must be subtracted from the 1,428,000 new service jobs to arrive at the net job gain figure.

The new service jobs account for more than 100% of the net new jobs.

Keep in mind, too, that many of the new jobs are not filled by American citizens.

Many of the engineering and science jobs were filled by foreigners brought in on work visas. Indians and others from abroad can be hired to work in the US for one-third less. The engineering and science jobs that are offshored are paid as little as one-fifth of the US salary. Even foreign nurses are brought in on work visas. No one knows how many of the hospital orderlies are illegals.

What a super new economy Americans have! US job growth has a distinctly third world flavor.

A very small percentage of 2007's new jobs required a college education. Since there are so few jobs for university graduates, how is "education the answer"?

Where is the benefit to Americans of offshoring? The answer is that the benefit is confined to a few highly paid executives who receive multi-million dollar bonuses for increasing profits by offshoring jobs. The rest of the big money went to Wall Street manipulators who sold trusting people subprime derivatives.

"Free traders" will assert that the benefit is in low Wal-Mart prices. But the prices are low only because China keeps its currency pegged to the dollar. Thus, the Chinese currency value falls with the dollar. The peg will not continue forever. The dollar has lost 60% of its value against the Euro during the years of 2001 - 2007. Already China is having to adjust the peg. When the peg goes, Wal-Mart shoppers will think they are in Neiman Marcus.

Just as Americans have been betrayed by "their" leaders in government at all levels, they have been betrayed by business "leaders" on Wall Street and in the corporations. US government and business elites have proven themselves to be Americans' worst enemies.

Paul Craig Roberts was Assistant Secretary of the Treasury in the Reagan administration. He was Associate Editor of the Wall Street Journal editorial page.

Sunday, December 30, 2007


Free Trade or Fair Trade?

Friday, December 28, 2007

Site of Tract of Land at Manakin Town, Virginia For French Refugees Who Fled Religous Persecution in France in 17th Century


The Evangelical Rebellion
Dec 23, 2007
By Chris Hedges


The rise of Mike Huckabee as a presidential candidate represents a seismic shift in the tactics, ideology and direction of the radical Christian right. Huckabee may stumble and falter in later primaries, but his right-wing Christian populism is here to stay. Huckabee represents a new and potent force in American politics, and the neocons and corporate elite, who once viewed the yahoos of the Christian right as the useful idiots, are now confronted with the fact that they themselves are the ones who have been taken for a ride. Members of the Christian right, recruited into the Republican Party and manipulated to vote against their own interests around the issues of abortion and family values, are in rebellion. They are taking the party into new, uncharted territory. And they presage, especially with looming economic turmoil, the rise of a mass movement that could demolish what is left of American democracy and set the stage for a Christian fascism.

The corporate establishment, whose plundering of the country created fertile ground for a radical, right-wing backlash, is sounding the alarm bells. It is scrambling to bolster Mitt Romney, who, like Rudy Giuliani or Hillary Clinton, will continue to slash and burn on behalf of corporate profits. Columnist
George Will called Huckabee’s populism “a comprehensive apostasy against core Republican beliefs.” He wrote that Huckabee’s candidacy “broadly repudiates core Republican policies such as free trade, low taxes, the essential legitimacy of America’s corporate entities and the market system allocating wealth and opportunity.” National Review’s Rich Lowry wrote that “like [Howard] Dean, his nomination would represent an act of suicide by his party.”

Huckabee spoke of this revolt on the “Today” show. “There’s a sense in which all these years the evangelicals have been treated very kindly by the Republican Party,” he said. “They wanted us to be a part of it. And then one day one of us actually runs and they say, ‘Oh, my gosh, now they’re serious.’ They [evangelicals] don’t want to just show up and vote, they actually would want to be a part of the discussion.”

George Bush is a happy stooge of his corporate handlers. He blithely enriches the oligarchy, defends a war that is the worst foreign policy blunder in American history and callously denies medical benefits to children. Huckabee is different. He has tapped into the rage and fury of the working class, dispossessed and abandoned by the mainstream Democrats and Republicans. And he refuses to make the ideology of the Christian right, with its dark contempt for democratic traditions and intolerance of nonbelievers, a handmaiden of the corporate establishment. This makes him a much more lethal and radical political force.

The Christian right is the most potent and dangerous mass movement in American history. It has been controlled and led, until now, by those who submit to the demands of the corporate state. But the grass roots are tired of being taken for rubes. They are tired of candidates, like Bush or Bill Clinton, who roll out the same clichĂ©s about working men and women every four years and then spend their terms enriching their corporate backers. The majority of American citizens have spent the last two decades watching their government services and benefits vanish. They have seen their jobs go overseas and are watching as their communities crumble and their houses are foreclosed. It is their kids who are in Iraq and Afghanistan. The old guard in the Christian right, the Pat Robertsons, who used their pulpits to deliver the votes of naive followers to the corporatists, is a spent force. Huckabee’s Christian populism represents the maturation of the movement. It signals the rise of a truly radical, even revolutionary force in American politics, of which Huckabee may be one of the tamer and less frightening examples.

Hints of Huckabee’s bizarre worldview seep out now and then. Bob Vander Plaats, Huckabee’s Iowa campaign manager, for example, when asked about his candidate’s lack of foreign policy experience,
told MSNBC: “Well, I think Gov. Huckabee has a lot of resources that he goes to on national security matters. Here’s a guy, a former pastor, who understands a theological nature of this war as we’re fighting a radical religion in Islam.”

Robert Novak noted that Huckabee held a fundraiser last week at the Houston home of Dr. Steven Hotze.
As Novak wrote, Hotze is “a leader in the highly conservative Christian Reconstruction movement.”

Huckabee has close ties with the Christian Reconstructionist or
Dominionist branch of the Christian right. The Dominionist movement, which seeks to cloak itself in the mantle of the Christian faith and American patriotism, is small in numbers but influential. It departs from traditional evangelicalism. It seeks to redefine traditional democratic and Christian terms and concepts to fit an ideology that calls on the radical church to take political power. It shares many prominent features with classical fascist movements, at least as such movements are defined by the scholar Robert O. Paxton, who sees fascism as “a form of political behavior marked by obsessive preoccupation with community decline, humiliation, or victimhood and by compensatory cultures of unity, energy, and purity, in which a mass-based party of committed nationalist militants, working in uneasy but effective collaboration with traditional elites, abandons democratic liberties and pursues with redemptive violence and without ethical or legal restraints goals of internal cleansing and external expansion.”

Dominionism, born out of Christian Reconstructionism, seeks to politicize faith. It has, like all fascist movements, a belief in magic along with leadership adoration and a strident call for moral and physical supremacy of a master race, in this case American Christians. It also has, like fascist movements, an ill-defined and shifting set of beliefs, some of which contradict each other. Paxton argues that the best way to understand authentic fascist movements, which he says exist in all societies, including democracies, is to focus not on what they say but on how they act, for, as he writes, some of the ideas that underlie fascist movements “remain unstated and implicit in fascist public language” and “many of them belong more to the realm of visceral feelings than to the realm of reasoned propositions.”

Dominionism teaches that American Christians have been mandated by God to make America a Christian state. A decades-long refusal by most American fundamentalists to engage in politics at all following
the Scopes trial has been replaced by a call for Christian “dominion” over the nation and, eventually, over the Earth itself. Dominionism preaches that Jesus has called on Christians to actively build the kingdom of God on Earth. America becomes, in this militant Biblicism, an agent of God, and all political and intellectual opponents of America’s Christian leaders are viewed, quite simply, as agents of Satan. Under Christian dominion, America will no longer be a sinful and fallen nation but one in which the Ten Commandments form the basis of our legal system, in which creationism and “Christian values” form the basis of our educational system, and the media and the government proclaim the Good News to one and all. Labor unions, civil rights laws and public schools will be abolished. Women will be removed from the work force to stay at home, and all those deemed insufficiently Christian will be denied citizenship.

Baptist minister Rick Scarborough, founder of
Vision America and a self-described “Christocrat,” who attended the Texas fundraiser, has endorsed Huckabee. Scarborough, along with holding other bizarre stances, opposes the HPV (human papillomavirus) vaccine on grounds that it interferes with God’s punishment of sexual license. And Huckabee, who once advocated isolating AIDS patients from the general public and opposed increased federal funding in the search for a cure, comes out of this frightening mold. He justified his call to quarantine those with AIDS because they could “pose a dangerous public health risk.”

"If the federal government is truly serious about doing something with the AIDS virus, we need to take steps that would isolate the carriers of this plague,” Huckabee wrote. “It is difficult to understand the public policy towards AIDS. It is the first time in the history of civilization in which the carriers of a genuine plague have not been isolated from the general population, and in which this deadly disease for which there is no cure is being treated as a civil rights issue instead of the true health crisis it represents.”

Huckabee has publicly backed off from this extreme position, but he remains deeply hostile to gays. He has used wit and humor to deflect reporters from his radical views about marriage, abortion, damnation, biblical law, creationism and the holy war he believes we are fighting with Islam. But his stances represent a huge step, should they ever become policy, toward a theocratic state and the death of our open society. In the end, however, I do not blame Huckabee or the tens of millions of hapless Christians—40 percent of the Republican electorate—who hear his words and rejoice. I blame the corporate state, those who thought they could disempower and abuse the working class, rape the country, build a rapacious oligarchy and never pay a political price.


Chris Hedges, who graduated from seminary at Harvard Divinity School, is the author of “American Fascists: The Christian Right and the War on America.”

Thursday, December 27, 2007


Wisdom From The Founding Rationalists .... Jefferson and Adams
By David IgnatiusThursday, December 27, 2007; A17

A bracing text for this Christmas week is the famous correspondence between John Adams and Thomas Jefferson. Their letters are a reminder that the Founders were men of the Enlightenment -- supreme rationalists who would have found the religiosity of much of our modern political life quite abhorrent.

It's not that these men didn't have religious beliefs: They were, to their deaths, passionate seekers of truth, metaphysical as well as physical. It's that their beliefs didn't fit into pious cubbyholes. Indeed, the deist Jefferson took a pair of scissors to the New Testament to create his "Jefferson Bible," or, formally, "The Life and Morals of Jesus of Nazareth," which cut out the parts he regarded as supernatural or misinterpreted by the Gospel writers. It's useful to examine the musings of these American rationalists in this political season when religion has been a prominent topic.


Politicians and commentators have suggested that for the Founders, the very idea of freedom was God-given -- or, as the Declaration of Independence puts it, that human beings are "endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights." Yet this famous passage begins with a distillation of the Enlightenment's celebration of human reason: "We hold these truths to be self-evident."

My Christmastime reading of the Adams-Jefferson letters was prompted by this year's most interesting political speech -- Mitt Romney's Dec. 6 speech on "Faith in America." It was a fine evocation of our twin heritage of religion and religious freedom, until he got to this ritual denunciation of the bogeymen known as secularists.


"They seek to remove from the public domain any acknowledgment of God. Religion is seen as merely a private affair with no place in public life. It is as if they are intent on establishing a new religion in America -- the religion of secularism."

Anyone who reads Adams and Jefferson -- or for that matter, Benjamin Franklin, James Madison, Alexander Hamilton or other voices of the American Enlightenment -- can make their own judgment about what the Founders would say about secularism. My guess is that their response would be something like: "That is bunkum...."

Many of the Founders liked to speak of the "God of Nature," notes Garrett Epps, a professor of constitutional law at the University of Oregon. Adams used this term in a June 20, 1815, letter to Jefferson: "The question before the human race is, whether the God of nature shall govern the world by His own laws, or whether priests and kings shall rule it by fictitious miracles?" Adams mistrusted priests and kings, but he was also skeptical of the revolutionary philosophers who had overthrown them in France. He spent his life looking for a middle ground.

Jefferson spoke in a May 5, 1817, letter of "true religion" as based on "moral precepts, innate in man," and the "sublime doctrine of philanthropism and deism taught us by Jesus of Nazareth." He contrasted this true faith with "sectarian dogmas." If the sectarian version prevailed, warned Jefferson, then he might agree with Adams's speculation that "this would be the best of all possible worlds if there were no religion in it."

Before leaving these men and their ruminations on man and God in what one editor of the letters called "an epistolary duet," let us recall this caustic Nov. 4, 1816, missive from Adams: "We have now, it seems, a national Bible Society, to propagate King James's Bible through all nations. Would it not be better to apply these pious subscriptions to purify Christendom from the corruptions of Christianity than to propagate those corruptions in Europe, Asia, Africa, and America?"

The Founders certainly believed in God, but for most of them, their faith was a deeply private matter, as Jefferson put it in a Jan. 11, 1817, letter, a subject "known to my God and myself alone." Indeed, they found loud, public displays of religiosity a profanation of this inner and spiritual practice of religion. Adams, the more conventionally "religious" of the two, insisted in a Sept. 14, 1813, letter that there is "but one being who can understand the universe, and that it is not only vain but wicked for insects to pretend to comprehend it."

One theme in this year's political campaign has been whether the United States will move from the faith-based policies the Bush administration has celebrated to a more rationalist and secular approach.


In this debate, religious conservatives like to stress their connection to the Founders and to the republic's birth as "one nation under God."

But a rereading of the Adams-Jefferson letters is a reminder that in this debate, the Founders -- as men of the Enlightenment -- would surely have sided with the party of Reason.




Wednesday, December 12, 2007


Romney and The Bill of Rights

Brigham Young, the second President and Prophet of the LDS Church, taught the belief that it is the right of "...every class of worshipers [to be] most strictly protected in their municipal rights and in the privileges of worshiping who, what, and when they please, not infringing upon the rights of others."

Last week in the second part of Romney's religion speech, he displayed a vastly limited knowledge of history, most of all, surprisingly, a limited knowledge of the history of the faith to which he adheres, and not unsurprisingly, the mission that many of the Fundamentalist Evangelicals have for the people of the United States: the dismantling of the Wall of Separation of Church and State, a central tenant of their mission; but to give Romney benefit of the doubt, it is probable that he may not know that; but if he does, indeed, have some idea of that part of their mission, then he demonstrates a lack of perception of long term probabilities of cause and effect.


While he tells us in the first part of last week's speech that he believes in the Separation of Church and State, in the second part his words show that he would undermind the "Establishment Clause" of the
Constitution's First Amendment:

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."

Romney made it clear that he has a limited understanding of the first amendment of the United States Constitution that not only protects one's right to believe and practice a religion - which he tells us he believes - but that he has a very limited understanding of the whole Bill of Rights, having previously told us, in the presidential candidates debate in May 2007, that habeas corpus was not a right of prisoners held without charges at the United States' military base at Guantanamo when he said:

".....I'm glad they're at Guantanamo. I don't want them on our soil. I want them at Guantanamo where they don't get the access to lawyers that they'd get when they're on our soil. I don't want them in our prisons, I want them there. Some people say that we should close Guantanamo, my view is: We outta double Guantanamo." He then finished: "Enhanced interrogation techniques need to be used." .

in which he further demonstrated his lack of knowledge of Brigham Young's municipal rights, the other part of the First Amendment, as well, as the teachings in the Book of Mormon and the LDS Church's Articles of Faith.


The LDS Church's 12th Article of Faith instructs its members to obey, honor and sustain the law. Advocating the denial of basic legal rights is in direct contradiction to this article and the 13th Article teaches LDS members to be benevolent, virtuous and good to all men. How "enhanced interrogation techniques" fits into being benevolent, virtuous, or good, which Article of Faith implies justice, he does not explain. Both in the Bible and in the Book of Mormon, Christ taught:


"And behold it is written also, that thou shalt love thy neighbor and hate thy enemy, but I say unto you, love your enemies, bless them that curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for them who despitefully use you and persecute you. That you may be the children of your Father who is in heaven."


In the LDS book of Doctrine and Covenants, Christ says:

"And that law of the land which is constitutional, supporting that principle of freedom in maintaining rights and privileges, belongs to all mankind, and is justifiable before me."

One would think that "all mankind" means there are no exceptions.


In the Book of Mormon, in Alma, Chapter 14, when Alma and Amulek were in Zarahemla, they were smittened and imprisioned and their accusers "sought to put them away privily", intending to prevent them a hearing before the court and judges of the law, ie: deny them of their municipal rights of habeas corpus. That, is as all Mormons should know, is exactly what happened to Joseph Smith and his brother, Hyrum. And to put anyone "away privily" could mean any number of things including to disappear them in whatsoever manner their accusers pleased.


Then, finally, in the Book of Alma, Chapter 30, verses 7-10, there was


"no law against a man's belief, for it was strictly contrary to the commands of God that there should be a law.... for thus saith the scripture: Choose ye this day, whom ye shall serve. Now if a man desired to serve God, it was his privilege; or rather if he believed in God, it was his privilege to serve him; but if he did not believe in him there was no law to punish him."


The only laws on the books in the nation of Zarahemla were laws against crimes of person and property, which is defined in verse 11 of Alma Chapter 30,


"For there was a law that men should be judged according to their crimes. Nevertheless, there was no law against a man's belief; therefore a man was punished only for the crimes which he had done; therefore all men were on equal grounds."


Romney, then, seems to only not understand the laws of the United States and righteous laws throughout the world, he seems to not understand, or know that much of the history of Joseph Smith, after the restoration of the gospel, was in violation the Bill of RIghts, not only the right of him and the members of the LDS church to worship as they saw fit, but a continued violation of their municipal rights as we see in the above quotes from scripture and doctrine of the LDS Church.

At no time does Mormon belief support anything that would take away the freedom of the individual to decide for himself how to think and proceed on any matter, except for violations of the rights of persons and property of another, which are crimes. The issues that currently divide the present population including the right to life, gay marriage, the current war for hegemony over the world's natural resources for power and gain, and all other issues of any kind that have polarized the people of this country, including the right to freely worship who, what, and where they please or not do so, if they so please, Romney, in trying to make common cause with the various sects of Fundamentalist Evangelicals, forsakes that which he professes that which is not negotiable -- the teachings of his faith.

His speech, directed at a small population, told them, as well as the population at large, that he shares their position to dismantle the First Amendment and the whole of the Constitution's Bill of Rights, by appointing judges inclined to adhere to idealogical positions, rather than rule of law. He saw secularism as "a new religion in America" -- in violation of the teachings of the Book of Mormon that man also has the right to be protected in not believing in God -- and his statement on secularism implies a desire for the state to address this concern; but how to address it, he did not say. Appointing judges who would do away with anything that bespeaks of no belief in God in violation of the teachings in the Book of Mormon and LDS Church doctrine?

The Constitution does not mention God any place in it.  It is a completely secular document, and it only mentions religion in the negative sense. Romney says that he is sympathetic to those who would place some religious symbols and religious texts in taxpayer funded facilities, which would of course include the Ten Commandments. Which version of four versions of the Ten Commandments would he advocate? The Old Testament? The Catholic Vulgate? The Book of Mormon? The Torah? Which of the religious symbols would he exclude? Islam has none, so there would be no decision there to make there, since Moslems believe that all religious symbols are forms of idolatry, and, indeed, a former President of the LDS Church, George Albert Smith, said - paraphrasing - that God brought forth Mohammed to rid the world of idolatry, so no need to square that one. Such a discussion presents a serious delemma for any nation when the rule law runs into the wall of a religious culture.

Romney praised America's "symphony of faith" while failing to utter a single word about the millions of American citizens who do not kneel "in prayer to the Almighty."   What of the Buddhists, the Hindi, Sikkhs, the Hottentots, the tribal religions and other lesser known religions and practices whose adherents have migrated to the US? This was no oversight, as some commentators have speculated; it was an expression of ideology. Mitt Romney's America is a country defined by its Christian majority and will tolerate non-believers, only at a price: the price of exclusion from the nation's presumed theological identity.

In his eagerness to champion the Fundamentalist Evangelical tendentious views of American history and culture in his campaign to be president, Romney has opened a can of worms and those worms will have their say.  If he continues, he will have boxed himself in and have no way out and he will have then opened up the cherished beliefs and practices of millions of people to ridicule and disparagment by whomever can obtain an audience.

Religion is a seriously private concern and the First Amendment protects everyone, as Brigham Young said, in their privileges. The common ground for all people in the United States is not the Bible, the Book of Mormon, the Koran, Confuscian, or Buddhists' or Hindi, or any other religious tenet or belief; it is the Constitution of the United States and its Bill of Rights. We put in peril all beliefs and practices that do not violate the person or property of another when we do not support the Constitution of the United States and its Bill of Rights.



Tuesday, December 11, 2007


A Coherent View of the Founding of the United States

Political professor of political science University of Chicago writes:

“….reflections on the role of religion in American politics implicitly called to mind a disturbingly distorted version of history that has become part of the conventional wisdom of American politics in recent years.

That version of history suggests that the Founders intended to create a "Christian Nation," and that we have unfortunately drifted away from that vision of the United States. In fact, nothing could be further from the truth.

Those who promote this fiction confuse the Puritans, who intended to create a theocratic state, with the Founders, who lived 150 years later. The Founders were not Puritans, but men of the Enlightenment. They lived not in an Age of Faith, but in an Age of Reason. They viewed issues of religion through a prism of rational thought.

To be sure, there were traditional Christians among the Founders, including such men as John Jay, Patrick Henry and Samuel Adams. Most of the Founders, however, were not traditional Christians, but deists who were quite skeptical of traditional Christianity. They believed that a benevolent Supreme Being had created the universe and the laws of nature and had given man the power of reason with which to discover the meaning of those laws.

They viewed religious passion as irrational and dangerously divisive, and they challenged, both publicly and privately, the dogmas of traditional Christianity. Benjamin Franklin, for example, dismissed most of Christian doctrine as "unintelligible." He believed in a deity who "delights" in man's "pursuit of happiness." He regarded Jesus as a wise moral philosopher, but not necessarily as a divine or divinely inspired figure. He viewed all religions as more or less interchangeable in their most fundamental tenets, which he believed required men to treat each other with kindness and respect.

Thomas Jefferson was a thoroughgoing skeptic who valued reason above faith. He subjected every religious tradition, including his own, to careful scrutiny. He had no patience for talk of miracles, revelation, and resurrection. Like Franklin, Jefferson admired Jesus as a moral philosopher, but insisted that Jesus' teachings had been distorted beyond all recognition by a succession of "corruptors," such as Paul, Augustine, and Calvin. He regarded such doctrines as predestination, trinitarianism, and original sin as "nonsense," "abracadabra" and "a deliria of crazy imaginations." He referred to Christianity as "our peculiar superstition" and maintained that "ridicule" was the only rational response to the "unintelligible propositions" of traditional Christianity.

John Adams, who identified most closely with the early Unitarians, also believed that the original teachings of Jesus had been sound, but that Christianity had subsequently gone awry. He wrote to Jefferson that the essence of his religious beliefs was captured in the phrase, "Be just and good." As President, Adams signed a treaty, unanimously approved by the Senate in 1797, stating unambiguously that "the Government of the United States . . . is not in any sense founded on the Christian religion."

George Washington was respectful of traditional Christianity, but he did not have much use for it. His personal papers offer no evidence that he believed in biblical revelation, eternal life, or Jesus' divinity. Clergymen who knew Washington well bemoaned his skeptical approach to Christianity. Bishop William White, for example, admitted that no "degree of recollection will bring to my mind any fact which would prove General Washington to have been a believer in Christian revelation."

Tom Paine, the author of Common Sense, The Rights of Man, and The Age of Reason, insisted that "the religion of Deism is superior to the Christian religion," because it "is free from those invented and torturing articles that shock our reason." Paine explained that deism's creed "is pure and sublimely simple. It believes in God, and there it rests. It honours Reason as the choicest gift of God to man" and "it avoids all presumptuous beliefs and rejects, as the fabulous inventions of men, all books pretending to revelation." Paine dismissed Christianity as "a fable, which, for absurdity and extravagance, is not exceeded by anything that is to be found in the mythology of the ancients." In Paine's view, traditional Christianity had "served to corrupt and brutalize mankind."

These words no doubt sound shockingly blunt and "politically incorrect" to modern ears, but they were in fact the views of many of our most revered Founders. The fable that the United States was founded as a Christian Nation is just that -- a fable.

It is worth noting that the Declaration of Independence does not invoke Jesus, or Christ, or Our Father, or the Almighty, but the "Laws of Nature," "Nature's God," the "Supreme Judge," and "Divine Providence," all phrases that belong to the tradition of deism. The Declaration of Independence is not a Puritan or Calvinist or Methodist or Baptist or Protestant or Catholic or Christian document, but a document of the Enlightenment. It is a statement that deeply and intentionally invokes the language of American deism. It is a document of its own time, and it speaks eloquently about what Americans of that time believed.

The Constitution goes even further. It does not invoke the deity at all. Unlike the Puritan documents of the early seventeenth century, it makes no reference whatever to God. It cites as its ultimate source of authority not "the command of God," but "We the People," the stated purpose of the Constitution is not to create a government "according to the will of God" but to "secure the Blessings of Liberty." Significantly, the only reference to religion in the 1789 Constitution expressly prohibits the use of any religious test for public office.

The Founders were not anti-religion. They understood that religion could help nurture the public morality necessary to a self-governing society. But they also understood that religion was fundamentally a private and personal matter that had no place in the political life of a nation dedicated to the separation of church and state. They would have been appalled at the idea of the federal government sponsoring "faith-based" initiatives. They would have been quite happy to tolerate Mitt Romney's Mormonism - as long as he keeps it out of our government.

.... Professor at University of Chicago



Thursday, December 06, 2007

Chipping Away At The Separation of Church and State

"Freedom is not lost by a sudden thrust in the dark of the night, but, by single imperceptable digits, one at a time..."
.... Dr. Roy O. McClain

Today Mitt Romney said:


"When I place my hand on the Bible and take the oath of office, that oath becomes my highest promise to God."

I say, the oath of office of the president of the United States is a promise to "We The People of the United States" to uphold the Constitution; it is not a promise to God on the Constitution to uphold the Bible, or the Book of Mormon, or the Koran, or any single religious text or belief, though that does not preclude the making of a promise to one's God to uphold the Constitution, if so inclined. One's relationship to one's religion is and should be of no issue or concern to the larger public.

Implicit in the oath of office of the president of the United States is, also, what Brigham Young said, is Mormon belief that "...every class of worshipers [are to be] most strictly protected in their municipal rights and in the privileges of worshiping who, what, and when they please, not infringing upon the rights of others".

In the first part of today's speech, Romney told us that he believes, with Brigham Young, in the protection of "...the privileges of worship who, what, and when they please, not infringing upon the rights of others"; however, in the second part of his speech he tells us his views on municipal rights with words that propose to undermine the "Establishment Clause" of the Constitution's First Amendment:

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."

Scarecrow has more on how his words propose to undermine the Constitution and he and says it better:

"You see, the framers understood that to keep a diverse nation from tearing itself apart in religious strife they had to preserve and protect two equally important principles: the one respecting the free exercise of religion, which Romney now invokes, and the other, which Romney seeks to undermine, prohibiting the state from establishing religion.

It's on this latter principle where Romney sends a [message] to the fundamentalists who most distrust his religious views. When he says he shares their views, he means he shares the view that government should be free to undermine the establishment clause when promoting those religious tenets that he and the fundamentalists share. We hear that message throughout the speech, but to set the stage, Romney first performs an intellectual sleight of hand.

"There are some who may feel that religion is not a matter to be seriously considered in the context of the weighty threats that face us. If so, they are at odds with the nation's founders, for they, when our nation faced its greatest peril, sought the blessings of the Creator. And further, they discovered the essential connection between the survival of a free land and the protection of religious freedom. In John Adam's words: 'We have no government armed with power capable of contending with human passions unbridled by morality and religion. ... Our Constitution was made for a moral and religious people.'"

[Where does that leave the views noted in the Treaty of Tripoli signed by John Adams on June 10, 1797 that contains the clause: "As the government of the United States of America is not in any sense founded on the Christian Religion"? [Seems to me that John Adams was saying that morality and religion are not confined to just the Christian religion. editor's note.]

Note that when Romney is quoting the founders, the survival of freedom is explicitly linked to religious freedom. But then Romney does a bait and switch in the next paragraph:

"Freedom requires religion just as religion requires freedom. Freedom opens the windows of the soul so that man can discover his most profound beliefs and commune with God. Freedom and religion endure together, or perish alone.
So the original principle was that freedom and religious freedom are indivisible; that is, one is part of the other."

When Romney translates it, freedom and religion require each other, and that's the wedge he then uses to undermine the Establishment Clause in the First Amendment. He then starts chipping away:

"No religion should dictate to the state nor should the state interfere with the free practice of religion. [note that in the following the establishment prohibition is now missing] But in recent years, the notion of the separation of church and state has been taken by some well beyond its original meaning. They seek to remove from the public domain any acknowledgment of God. Religion is seen as merely a private affair with no place in public life. It is as if they are intent on establishing a new religion in America -- the religion of secularism. They are wrong. The founders proscribed the establishment of a state religion, but they did not countenance the elimination of religion from the public square. We are a nation 'Under God' and in God, we do indeed trust.

Most Americans would say, "well that's probably okay," but he's not done. Having said it's okay to limit the scope of the Establishment Clause, he goes on to assure the fundamentalists, who want to strangle that clause, that he's sympathetic:

'We should acknowledge the Creator as did the founders -- in ceremony and word. He should remain on our currency, in our pledge, in the teaching of our history, and during the holiday season, nativity scenes and menorahs should be welcome in our public places. Our greatness would not long endure without judges who respect the foundation of faith upon which our Constitution rests. I will take care to separate the affairs of government from any religion, but I will not separate us from 'the God who gave us liberty.'

"Ceremony and word"? Does that mean laws? Or faith-based initiatives run out of the White House? And what does he mean by "teaching of our history?" Isn't that a message to teaching religion -- read: our common Christian religion -- in public schools? And how should we interpret Romney's new litmus test for federal judges, if not as a requirement that they be willing to endorse government efforts to chip away at the Establishment Clause?

Romney continues:

"In such a world, we can be deeply thankful that we live in a land where reason and religion are friends and allies in the cause of liberty, joined against the evils and dangers of the day. [That seems to be Muslims, I think.] And you can be certain of this: Any believer in religious freedom, any person who has knelt in prayer to the Almighty, has a friend and ally in me."

Then, where does that leave those who have not knelt in prayer?" (End of Scarecrow quote.)

Ted Sorensen on CNN then demonstrates that the ideas on the separation of church and state of John F. Kennedy are entirely different from the ones in Mitt Romney's speech:

"...JFK wanted to particularly stress that he believed in the separation between church and state. He believed that no one needed to worry about a Catholic bishop or a cardinal dictating to him as a president, and that freedom of religion included freedom for those to go to any church or not to go to any church at all. So, Romney emphasized the role of religion in public life more strongly than JFK did or would have....Kennedy said, his views of religion were totally his business and not the business of the American people."

Peter Montgomery shows why the Romney's emphasis is different from the JFK emphasis:

"...Romney in a dramatically different situation (from the JFK speech in 1960) is in a heated primary race, losing conservative evangelical Christian voters to Mike Huckabee, and walking a tightrope. He can’t make JFK’s appeal to church-state separation, because he’s trying to get support from people who think church-state separation is, in Pat Robertson’s phrase, a “lie of the left.” Ditto for an appeal to religious tolerance, not a high priority for the “Christian nation” crowd.

Romney’s appeal is to try to convince Fundamentalist voters that they should care less about the theology of Mormonism and more about his pledge to support their religious policy priorities down the line, especially the dismantling of the wall separating church and state—and judges who agree. That’s been enough to win the support of some high-profile Fundamentalist leaders, including Paul Weyrich, Lou Sheldon and Jay Sekulow.

Thus, Romney finds himself in a bit of a box, partly of his own making. Given the power of the Fundamentalist voters in the GOP primary, and the de facto religious test many of them apply to the presidency, Romney has stressed the importance of electing a person of faith. But when he has tried to assure the Fundamentalist voters that he is a follower of Christ, he has drawn stern warnings from people like the Southern Baptists’
Richard Land, because many evangelicals view Mormonism as a cult.

According to http://pewforum.org/docs/?DocID=267

Pew polls, more than a third of white evangelicals, and more than 4 in 10 of evangelicals who attend church weekly, say they’re less likely to vote for a candidate who is Mormon. Says Land, “When he goes around and says Jesus Christ is my Lord and savior, he ticks off at least half the evangelicals.”

Mike Huckabee, in many ways the dream candidate for Fundamentalist voters, isn’t trying to make things any easier for Romney. While deflecting opportunities to comment directly on whether or not Mormons are Christians, Huckabee has encouraged others to ask Romney. “If we’re going to ask me about my faith, let’s ask all the candidates about theirs,” he
suggests. “Now as you noticed, I’m not hesitant or reluctant to talk about mine.”

In October, a prominent Dallas minister, Robert Jeffress, speaking of Romney, said, “It’s a little hypocritical for the last eight years to be talking about how important it is for us to elect a Christian president and then turn around and endorse a non-Christian,” he said. “Christian conservatives are going to have to decide whether having a Christian president is really important or not.”

The Fundamentalist's long public war on church-state separation and religious pluralism has been cheered on by Republican officials as long as it has been a weapon against Democratic candidates. But it’s not as much fun for them when the target is one of the GOP’s top contenders." (End of Peter Montgomery quote.)

Now from Peterr:

"From start to finish, Romney's speech this morning entitled "Faith in America" was a political -- not a religious -- speech. Romney wanted to say "I believe in the separation of church and state," yet he tried to reach out to evaneglicals who are moving toward Mike Huckabee and bring them back by saying in essence "Americans are people of faith, their leader must be a person of faith, and I'm the best faithful leader out there."

It's kind of hard to reconcile those two, but Mitt gave it a good try. The best way to do it, of course, is to go after the straw people. For instance, early in the speech Romney said, "But in recent years, the notion of the separation of church and state has been taken by some well beyond its original meaning. They seek to remove from the public domain any acknowledgment of God."

That's not quite it, exactly.

What "some" people want removed from the public domain is the government taking official notice of and granting preference to (a) religious beliefs over non-religious beliefs, and (b) favoring certain religious believers over others with different beliefs (religous or otherwise).

The Constitution says not one word about God, and refers to religion only twice -- and both times in the negative, to constrain the government's interaction with religion. People are free to impose a religious test (or any other kind of test, for that matter) on the candidates for office as they consider for whom they will vote; [but] the government cannot put such a test as a requirement for holding office. People are free to be religious or not; the government must be blind to religion.

There were many things in the speech that indicated to me the lack of knowledge...on Romney's part as to who believers are, what they think, and how they live.

But the bigger problem I saw in Romney's speech jumped out when he said this:

"It is important to recognize that while differences in theology exist between the churches in America, we share a common creed of moral convictions. And where the affairs of our nation are concerned, it's usually a sound rule to focus on the latter – on the great moral principles that urge us all on a common course. Whether it was the cause of abolition, or civil rights, or the right to life itself, no movement of conscience can succeed in America that cannot speak to the convictions of religious people."

For all Romney says about history in this speech, this paragraph is proof that his knowledge is very limited, indeed. Abolition of slavery, for instance, divided families, congregations, and entire denominations. The Presbyterians split in 1861, and didn't reunite until 1983, for crying out loud.

Despite his claim of a "common course" based on "great moral principles," there continues to be great division among religious people over all kinds of issues.

Committed Roman Catholics, for instance, interpret "right to life" to mean opposition to the death penalty; evangelical fundamentalists see the death penalty as a completely separate issue. Some religious groups embrace GLBTs, while others do not. Yet Romney, trying to reach the evangelicals who are moving toward Huckabee, blithely says in essence, "all religious folks have the same moral beliefs." However, the above instances note that that is not true.

"We face no greater danger today than theocratic tyranny," says Romney -- but he makes it clear he is talking only about "radical Islam."

Romney's language about America's churches having a common moral creed and his assumption that every American is religious points to a different kind of tyranny when he says, "And you can be certain of this: Any believer in religious freedom, any person who has knelt in prayer to the Almighty, has a friend and ally in me."

Where once again does that leave those who have not knelt in prayer to the Almighty?

The bottom line for Romney is that he has to reach out to the fundamentalist evangelical voters. He mouths the words about separation of church and state to mollify moderates, but his strongest language is aimed directly at the evangelicals who are leaning toward Huckabee and others on the right, telling them that he's a good, religious guy -- and Americans need a good religious leader in the White House.

Lots of the pre-speech hype and post-speech spin has compared this speech with John F. Kennedy's address to the Greater Houston Ministerial Association. In comparing the actual speeches, though, the endings make clear that Romney and Kennedy are two very different kinds of politicians, trying to reach two very different kinds of people.

Kennedy said this to close his speech:

"But if, on the other hand, I should win this election, then I shall devote every effort of mind and spirit to fulfilling the oath of the Presidency -- practically identical, I might add, with the oath I have taken for 14 years in the Congress. For without reservation, I can, "solemnly swear that I will faithfully execute the office of President of the United States, and will to the best of my ability preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution -- so help me God."

Compare that with Romney's conclusion:

"Recall the early days of the First Continental Congress in Philadelphia, during the fall of 1774. With Boston occupied by British troops, there were rumors of imminent hostilities and fears of an impending war. In this time of peril, someone suggested that they pray. But there were objections. 'They were too divided in religious sentiments', what with Episcopalians and Quakers, Anabaptists and Congregationalists, Presbyterians and Catholics. Then Sam Adams rose, and said he would hear a prayer from anyone of piety and good character, as long as they were a patriot. And so together they prayed, and together they fought, and together, by the grace of God ... they founded this great nation. In that spirit, let us give thanks to the divine 'author of liberty.' And together, let us pray that this land may always be blessed, 'with freedom's holy light.' God bless the United States of America."

Kennedy's last word is from the constitution and Romney's is a story about prayer. Kennedy wants to speak to all Americans; Romney wants to reach the evangelical fundamentalists." (End of Peterr quote.)

So, now, what do we have here? Courtesy of the International Herald Tribune:

James Dobson, founder of Focus on the Family, called Romney’s speech “a magnificent reminder of the role religious faith must play in government and public policy.” He added, “Whether it will answer all the questions and concerns of evangelical Christian voters is yet to be determined, but the governor is to be commended for articulating the importance of our religious heritage as it relates to today.”

Sounds like Dobson is opening the door to further conversations with Romney. It’s a lot more of a welcome than Rudy’s ever going to get.

And this from E. J. Dionne, columnist from the Washington Post:

"... “Freedom,” he said, “requires religion just as religion requires freedom.”
And to those who see religion as “merely a private affair with no place in public life,” he had this to say: “It is as if they are intent on establishing a new religion in America—the religion of secularism. They are wrong.”

Well. Religion can certainly be conducive to freedom. But does freedom require religion? Is religion always conducive to freedom? Does freedom not also thrive in far more secular societies than our own? Isn’t the better course for our nation to seek solidarity among lovers of liberty, secular as well as religious? After all, it was a coalition of believers and secularists, as the Princeton scholar Jeffrey Stout has noted, that sent a communist dictatorship tumbling down in Pope John Paul II’s native Poland.

And Romney’s knock on the “religion of secularism” was pure pandering to the religious right. I hope Romney’s eloquence about “our grand tradition of religious tolerance and liberty” persuades voters who need convincing that it would be terribly divisive if his Mormonism were a factor in how he fares in the primaries. I wish he had felt less need to water down his boldness with politically convenient assertions that would also divide us, just in different ways. "


Now, Kevin Drum:

"....Romney is doing nothing more than engaging in what's become routine disparagement of those who aren't religious. Not only does Romney not have the courage to speak in even a single passing phrase about the nonreligious, as JFK did, he went out of his way to insist that "freedom requires religion," that no movement of conscience is possible without religion, and that judges had better respect our "foundation of faith" lest our country's entire greatness disappear."

And Joan Walsh:

"Romney blasted "the new religion of secularism," referring to those who continue to argue for strict separation of church and state, which apparently, like certain of the Geneva Conventions under the Bush administration, is becoming "quaint." I sometimes find the anti-God stridency of Richard Dawkins and Christopher Hitchens grating. Listening to Romney's speech I realized what a necessary corrective it is to corrosive political pandering. Calling secularism "religion" is a cheap shot not worthy of a major presidential candidate."

Even Sally Quinn theVillage Sunday School teacher and society hostess said this:

"...I have to say that I'm really stunned because I think it was an obliteration of the idea of the separation of church and state. He eliminated anybody who was a doubter, an atheist, an agnostic, a seeker. It's like, if you believe in God or Christ, if not, you're not."

"Christianity neither is, nor ever was a part of the common law," wroteThomas Jefferson in a letter to Dr. Thomas Cooper, February 10, 1814.

David Kuo pointed out that this whole discussion stokes division among all Americans and that it was wrong for him not to include non-believers among the American family.

Here are some very interesting takes on Mitt's speech at BeliefNet.

Steve Waldman:

"About three percent of the population are atheists or agnostics, according to a study by the Pew Religious Forum. Another 7.5% are secularists who have no religious affiliation and few or no religious beliefs or practices.That means there are four or five times as many non-believers as there are Mormons. A candidate declaring his distaste for a particular demographic group in this way has said that 22 million possible votes are of no matter to him. Non believers and secularists may not be a big voting bloc in the Republican primaries, but 10.5% is roughly 22 million people."

All Protestant faiths are offshoots of the Catholic faith, in whose eyes Protestants are often viewed as heretics and "false" Christians. A knowledge of the history of Christianity shows this. The argument rehashes the same old tired question of whether Mormons are Christian... evangelicals must get over therir obsession with this question. Theology's main value is that it illuminates the ways in which we are all trying to find our own unique meaning in life. In terms of Christianity, there are several interpretations: Catholic Christianity, Protestant Christianity, Mormon Christianity, and many other strains of Christianity.

Most evangelicals are not afraid that a President Romney will impose his esoteric Mormon morality on the rest of us and not really worried he’ll try to ban caffeine (though Huckabee might), or hand out tax breaks for special religious articles.....and as one evangelical says:

"Evangelicals are afraid that nominating a Mormon will legitimize a cult. Can Romney say something can assuage that fear. He didn't say it today.

And for evangelicals this makes his faith a legitimate concern for GOP primary voters. Why? Because Mitt will depress turnout. Many voters who might otherwise pull the GOP lever will stay home debating whether it’s worse to mainstream Mormonism forever, therefore, faith aside, he’s the wrong choice because he’s less likely to win.

It doesn’t matter how convincingly Romney claims he’ll compartmentalize his faith. Nor does it matter if, say, Romney makes the Huckster his veep. In fact, Romney taints the ticket whether he’s the presidential OR the vice presidential nominee. This is what a lot of evangelicals really think but are afraid to say publicly.

Even if Romney was Mormon only by name I still believe that nominating him would help to legitimize the Mormon faith. Which is only a problem because I believe that the Mormon faith is false and damaging to our culture. However, that being said, there are more damaging things being legitimized everyday, and it is my choice to help or not to help legitimize them, as it it is my government given right to vote for a president of my choice for my own reasons, religious included.

The next question I need to ask my self is what is most important? There are things more important than not helping to legitimize a cult, certainly, but do other candidates offer a better alternative then compromising on this issue? Probably. But, if Romney can present himself as the best candidate above all others, it'll make it very hard not to vote for him.

All that being said I've heard it said that the best way to deal with a cult is to let them speak up about what they believe. To allow the light to shine in the the poorly lit areas and reveal. It might be a good idea to allow Mormonism to be more mainstream, it may open people's eyes to its twisted version of "christianity" and draw more critics. It is a very new religion, quick growth and powerful people do not legitimize it. Maybe the result will be like that of Tom Cruise and Scientology.
Posted by: James December 7, 2007 3:07 PM "

Founders' Views:

I have found Christian dogma unintelligible. Early in life I absented myself from Christian assemblies." ....Benjamin Franklin

"Religious bondage shackles and debilitates the mind and unfits it for every noble enterprise, every expanded prospect." ....James Madison

"Had you [Thomas Jefferson] and I been forty days with Moses on Mount Sinai and admitted to behold, the divine Shekinah, and there told that one was three and three, one: We might not have had courage to deny it, but we could not have believed it." ...John Adams

"The truth is that the greatest enemies to the doctrines of Jesus are those calling themselves the expositors of them, who have perverted them for the structure of a system of fancy absolutely incomprehensible, and without any foundation in his genuine words." ....-- Thomas Jefferson

"The Bible: a history of wickedness that has served to corrupt and brutalise mankind." ....Thomas Paine

"Do Mormans, like evangelical Christians believe in the concept of Heaven and Hell? Do good in this life and be rewarded with everlasting peace in Paradise. So Mitt, based on the teachings of your Morman faith, will Cheney and bush, 2 guys that lied this country into war, a war that has led to 10's of thousands of needless deaths, be rewarded with eternal salvation? Have they lived and acted in accordance with your deep Morman values? As Commander in Chief would you willfully lie to the American people and manipulate critical information to justify a war? Your answers will help us decide if you're suited to be President of the USA.

He dropped in evangelical code phrases and themes like the de-Christianization of Europe, the dangers of a secular America and America's godly heritage.... He said he was going to stand up for his faith and that he wasn't going to get into the business of theology. Then he did just that.

In the middle of the speech was this: There is one fundamental question about which I often am asked. What do I believe about Jesus Christ? I believe that Jesus Christ is the Son of God and the Savior of mankind. My church's beliefs about Christ may not all be the same as those of other faiths. Each religion has its own unique doctrines and history. These are not bases for criticism but rather a test of our tolerance. Religious tolerance would be a shallow principle indeed if it were reserved only for faiths with which we agree.

In that single paragraph he blew his chance to shut the door on the pastor-in-chief idea because he was, consciously or not, making the theological argument that Mormonism was basically a part of historic Christianity. And it is, in the judgment of most liberal and conservative Christian theologians, not a part of historic Christianity. The fact that we will now be debating this is evidence of the one paragraph gaffe.

Kennedy's 1960 speech succeeded in no small part because it was devoid of any religious sentiment. Nowhere in that speech did Kennedy say anything about what he believed. In fact, he said religion was a fundamentally private matter.

"...perhaps because he wanted evangelicals to know that Mike Huckabee wasn't the only one who could talk about Jesus, he did the theology thing. And now, instead of moving past this matter - as we should be doing because debating theology is decidedly not what presidential elections are supposed to be about..."

"All of this points to our very, very big problem. Our debate and discussion about faith and politics is, increasingly, just a discussion about faith. That is toxic for our politics and for our faith. We need to be having theological discussions. They are important and valuable. We certainly need to be talking about politics. Pick your reason why.
But we're not getting either one. Instead we are getting politically-inspired theology discussions and theologically-inspired political discussions. Someone needs to hit a reset button because this is one of the ways religious intolerance takes root.

Perhaps what our country could use right now is a pledge by all of the candidates for president to:

1) Declare they respect and admire the faith of every other candidate;

2) Admit that no particular religion qualifies or disqualifies anyone for the presidency;

3) Promise not to manipulate religion to advance their political agendas.

Yes it is a small thing, yes it is a symbolic thing, but it might begin to restore some sanity to our increasingly goofy faith and politics discussion.

They just might have written, religion is the lightning bug, and faith, the lightning bolt, while perhaps knowing that America would spend at least the next three hundred years trying to reverse those tenets in the pursuit of power, greed, personal aggrandizement, political domination and world-threatening behaviors like "nation-building".

"Some have made the love of God the foundation of morality. If we did a good act merely from the love of God and a belief that it is pleasing to Him, whence arises the morality of the atheist? ... Diderot, D’Alembert, D’Holbach, Condorcet, are known to have been among the most virtuous of men. Their virtue, then, must have had some other foundation than the love of God." ...Thomas Jefferson, from a letter to Thomas Law, 1814.

Freedom does not require religion. In fact, freedom from the tyranny of religion was the start of democratic governments in the western world. Putting an end to the divine right of kings as well as the divine connection of priests was and remains essential for freedom of thought and action. Romney's statement that this nation is not for those of us who believe rational thought can lead one to a proper life is mistaken. Most of the nation's Founding Father's would have been dismayed by this turn of events.

Hitchens and Dawkins and others have every right to their smug, smarmy, shallow contempt for religion, and to broadcast it as they see fit. That's a core principle of both my own religous ethics and what I understand of Constitutional law. But I really can't see them as "corrective" to theocratic pandering like Romney's. Rather, they just blindly hand him ammunition. They handily confirm the Christian right's boogeyman of combative, anti-faith non-believers, even as they stand alongside it and help uphold its lazy bigotry that there can be no tolerant, peaceful, liberal, or intellectually honest faith. Or any that joyfully respects a free, secular state with equal protection for all its citizens without regard to belief.

Romney's statement should be very disturbing to religious believers. Not only what he says to the rights of our non-religous fellow citizens...but what if Romney gets it into his head to define just what religion freedom requires? I doubt mine would make the cut.... " (comment by an atheist)

Religion, Inc.

America is where Christianity has come to die. It's not going to be a pretty death, either, at the rate the fundamentalists are going with it -- if ever a faith was more roundly gutted and compromised than American-style Christianity, it hasn't been invented, yet. The desired welding of Church(tm) and State(tm) is a recipe for dogmatic oblivion and crosscultural apocalypse. The revolution will be televangelized.

Rebuild that Jeffersonian Wall!

"It's Mr. Romney who deserves the opprobrium, not atheists or religious folks per se. The realization that he must kowtow to fundamentalist Protestants who hold the power in his party must be galling to him, yet he does it. He does it regardless of what he may or may not believe himself.

As a lifelong Catholic.... I hope for the reestablishment in our country of a strong wall of separation between ANY church and our state. Please, keep the creches and menorahs and satanic altars off the city hall steps; (by the way, who's going to answer the question as to which 10 commandments we're going to worship in the park? So far, they've never been the ones I know.)

Let kids who aren't part of the controlling religious culture get through their day without any pressures to pray from their teachers; get some historical sense ingrained into our citizens so they stop falling for the "Christian, godly founders" line. Let scientists teach science, not fairy tales. Let people love and partner with whomever they choose. End capital punishment and find compassionate and sensible ways to deal with undocumented immingrants. Find better ways to help the milions of voiceless poor in our rich nation. Vote for the candidates we think will do the best job, regardless of their religion, and regardless of which ones our religious leaders approve of. Donohue or Robertson, they sing from the same hymnal. Worry more about our own failings and a lot less about our neighbors'.

What a nice country that might be. I can go to church and my best friend can stay home, and our wives can meet at temple. We're all about as likely to end up in heaven as not, regardless. Well, if there is one....

Second, religious beliefs provide unique insight into the man or woman being examined. If a candidate says, for example, that he takes the Bible literally, as "the inspired word of God," then he is saying that he believes in the right to commit genocide in order to steal land, in slavery, in selling one's own daughter into slavery, in murdering one's own children for disobedience, that there was no death on Planet Earth prior to 4004 BC, that the sun can stop moving across the sky, etc.

While we cannot by law require a candidate to be of or not be of a particular religious persuasion, we have every right, indeed we have a duty to our nation to question every candidate tirelessly as to these kinds of questions so that we can judge the character of the man or woman. A candidate that believes the earth and every life form on it is only 6,000 years old rejects 99.9% of everything we have learned about science, about physics, and about the universe. I have a right (and desire) to know if the person I'm voting for rejects the full body of our scientific learning.

If, on the other hand, a candidate says that he believes the Bible but concedes that many of the stories therein should be read as metaphors rather than taken literally, we have different problem.

Which stories are true and which are just stories? How does one know? Dare I suggest that the picking and choosing is done to the advantage of the individual's own personal aims and needs? Is that not exactly what happened in the lead up to the invasion and occupation of Iraq?

Third, the Mormon issue is of specific concern because of how it plays along with these first two points. The vast majority of Americans – remember that Mormons make up less than two percent of our population – are deeply ignorant of what Mormons really believe and would immediately disqualify a Mormon candidate for president if said candidate ever spoke openly of those beliefs. (Mormons believe all non-Mormon Christians since the days of the Apostles are and were heretics, for one thing.)

Knowing what Mitt Romney or any other candidate believes is – or should be for any thinking person – an absolute requirement in the choice for president. The idea that we cannot ask about a candidate's faith or religious beliefs is preposterous. The fact that the press won’t ask about a candidate's faith or religious beliefs is criminal.

If you think religion does not play a role regardless of majority public opinions in almost everything our government does...you need only look to two hot button issues for the Fundamentalist Christians. More than 70% of Americans believe in a woman's right to choose and more than 75% of current active duty military personnel believe gays and lesbian should be able to serve openly, as they do in most all leading nations. But would Mitt Romney have a chance if he voiced support for either of these religion-based controversies?

Unless a candidate can stand before America's church leaders and declare, "My religious beliefs, my faith, will never influence any decision I make as president and will never influence any policy set forth by my administration, then we absolutely must know what those beliefs are. Furthermore, we (the people) did not introduce this discussion of faith in the first place. If the Fundamentalist Christians can make religion an issue in any way, then it must be examined and discussed as an issue. An issue because it is important to them.

Imagine a Jewish candidate. Will you not admit the absolute number one point of rejection by Republicans would be: He (or she) rejects Jesus Christ as the son of God? Tolerance for another's religious beliefs does not mean that you accept those beliefs as viable; rather, it means that you accept that a person has the right to hold those beliefs. A person's religious beliefs – fundamentalist, moderate, anti-theist – inform and guide in the most elementary ways. To anyone who suggests that a candidate's religious beliefs are not an issue, I need only direct you, once again, to our Current Occupant. Imagine if God had told him NOT to invade Iraq. Or, imagine if God told him to issue an executive order overturning Roe VS Wade. If he, with God's blessing, can destroy the Constitution without so much as whimper from the cowering general public, what's to stop him – or any other religion proponent – from throwing out one pesky little verdict?

If you do not know or bother to ask what a person believes, you have no cause to ever – not ever – complain when his or her belief system comes in opposition to your life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness". ...David, a Catholic. (End of quote)

Governor Romney :

"You roundly disregard the great diversity of religious beliefs and mislead your audience regarding historical facts demonstrating a need for an education in the areas of religion and history. To begin there are several of the more egregious errors I found in your speech:

Error 1) you appreciate “the ancient traditions of the Jews, unchanged through the ages.”

Not so, Judaism has changed considerably through the ages. In the United States alone there are three main branches of Judaism: Orthodox, Conservative, and Reform. There are traditional variations within and amongst each of them, and none of them practices Judaism the way it was practiced when the Temple of Solomon was around. Even in the time of Solomon, there were different sects of Jews, with differing traditions.

Error 2) you claim that all religions have “principles that urge us all on a common course. Whether it was the cause of abolition, or civil rights, or the right to life itself . . .”

Not so: All religions do not hold these values in common. In more modern times, your religion campaigned against a Constitutional Amendment that would have given equal rights to women. Other religions or their adherents were in favor of equal rights for women. Finally, what exactly do you mean by “the right to life itself?” If you mean that the government should have the ability to control women’s bodies, then no, not all religions favor that.

Error 3) you said, “during the holiday season, nativity scenes and menorahs should be welcome in our public places.”

You wrongly suppose that Judaism and Christianity are the country’s only two religions, or systems of belief.

Error 4) you said that we all, “believe that every single human being is a child of God.”

I know that members of your religion believe that, but lots of religions don’t. Most religions believe that we are God’s creations, but not that we are his children, other than in an adoptive sense.

Some Jews believe that G-d created Adam out of the Earth, and Eve from Adam, and that we are their descendants. Other Jews believe in evolution. Many Jews don’t even believe in God. Don’t be shocked. Many religions can function just fine without being God centered.

Error 5) you said, “No people in the history of the world have sacrificed as much for liberty.”

Our sacrifice has been miniscule compared with others. Look at plight of the Native Americans who we slaughtered and displaced to get this great country of ours. They sacrificed a lot more, and got a lot less.

Error 6) of World Wars I and II you said, “America took nothing from that Century's terrible wars.”

We got everything from those two wars. We became the world’s number one superpower.

Error 7) you said of Americans, “They came here from England to seek freedom of religion.”

Not so. Americans have come from all over the world. Some of them came from England. Some of them came from China. Some of them came because they had been sold into slavery. Our heritage as Americans is not merely and English one.

I hope you found this instructive. If you would like to continue your education, or you would just like to know more about how an atheistic Jew sees America, please don’t hesitate to give me a call."

To many Christians, not being able to persuade others to adopt their views is a loss of freedom... in putting up the Ten Commandments up in public buildings: which particular ten commandments would be used for that, the Jewish, Catholic, Protestant, or Mormon set?

The sooner that we stop using the rules of specific versions of Christianity to drive our political decision making and start sticking to principles (which are pretty common across religions), the better off we'll be.

Romney is telling conservative Christian voters that they should not be view him as the enemy because of his mormon faith. He tells them they should view him as an ally against the secular state.

The Founders of the Constitution of the United States believed:

"...specific religious practices were not to be the business of governments and secularism and atheism are to be tolerated. There is to be no religious test for election to office. Putting "in god we trust" on coins, opening Congress with a prayer, displaying creches,the ten commandments, and menorahs in the public square, are ok for me. Using government money for faith based programs that signifcantly promote a religion, or teaching religious practice in public schools clearly are not acceptable.

The Fundamentalists do not accept this. They believe that America was founded as a Christian nation and should function as one. The separation wall between church and state stipulated in the first amendment is to be demolished. They see the federal courts as the roadblock to this goal and have as their primary political objective to place enough like minded justices on the Supreme Court to nullify the first ammendment. This requires the religious right to gain the presidency and effective control of the Senate to effect this objective...left to their own devices, they would change the constitution to make christianity the national religion, restrict other religions, allow religious classes in public schools, and permit the spending of federal tax dollars on religious activities. These people believe they speak for God and they are not afraid to force the rest of us to live by their rules.

Thank goodness he spoke up! Now, we can truly understand Gov Romney's political idealogy and how they exclude all those who are not religious (in the way he defines religion). How can those who do not believe in a creator God have freedom? What country can they find and thrive in? Romney's stance here is cloaked with smiles, seeming reason and a false patriotism. Our government was designed to allow freedom of belief, and be inclusive; and from Romney's speech, he is proposing an inclusive/exclusive model, in what is widely viewed as a speech of pivotal importance, gives the thinking, open-minded voter ample grounds to disqualify the governor from this race."

"It would be nice if somebody in the media would be willing to ask Romney, plain and simple, how his contention that "secularism is dooming society and a good dose of religion is the answer" is any different than the contentions of Wahhabists and Taliban members who claim the exact same thing but with a different faith as the solution.

"...when Romney flipped on the abortion issue, he lost me. Not because we don't agree, but because he formed his initial pro-choice position as an adult, campaigning for it publicly. It was, presumably, the conclusion of an adult man as close to God then as he is now.

And yet, now, he feels completely different! While I think it is a sign of maturity to rethink a position, Romney didn't really display much when he flopped a 180 on the abortion issue. He saw that it wasn't possible to win the Republican nomination unless he compromised his principles, and so he did.

No wonder he's so anxious to get us to agree that 'freedom requires religion' - - since his stance on everything else is so malleable, taking this sort of global, nonsensensical stance gives him carte blanche to change this beliefs at will, so long as they are 'religious'.

For the record Dawkins and Hitchens are anti-organized religion, not anti-God. Not believing in something is quite different from being anti - something. Which religions? The summary left me wondering -- does Romney equate "religion" with just Judiasm, Christianity and Islam? Or is there room at his table for Buddhists, Hindus, and billions of other people as well? This isn't a rhetorical question since an increasing number of Americans follow those religions, both as native followers and converts. In my community the most popular "churches" in the local alternate newspaper's yearly ratings are a Unity church (#1) and a Shambhala Buddhist center (#2). Both would be alien places to most people.

If secularism is a religion... ...then, according to Romney, freedom requires it. "Freedom requires humility, love, and open-mindedness." In some contexts, that is the same as saying, "Freedom requires religion."

Romney's quotes on torture are much disturbing. As an atheist, why is it that to so many religions, "atheist" is synonymous with "immoral"? That somehow because I don't subscribe to any religion, I'll end breaking laws, killing people, crashing cars, breaking into houses, and whatnot? That I cannot possibly have a moral compass without religion?

There are far more laws and rules that govern my life, as an atheist than those found in religious texts. I happen to be a nice person. I mow the lawn, pick up my neighbor's mail, volunteer, and generally live a sane, lawful life.

If I hailed from India and explained to my Christian neighbors that I was Hindu, and celebrating Diwali, the Christian neighbors would think it was interesting, and welcome the diversity in their neighborhood. If I announced to my Christian neighbors publicly that I'm an atheist, I'm greeted with either sorrow or silence. Why? Why is it so frightening to religious people to have someone in their midst who just doesn't buy it? Why is it socially acceptable to say "I'm a Presbyterian" or "we're Jewish" or "my family is Mormon" but not "I'm an atheist"? Why does being an atheist feel like a dirty secret in America?

Freedom does NOT require religion. Freedom requires that people are allowed to practice their religions as they see fit, and also that people are allowed to NOT practice any religion and still be accepted members of society.

Romney uses exclusionary, repressive, totalitarian language against other Americans? Okay, I can understand - though never approve - that kind of talk about other countries; but Romney is advocating an antagonistic stance against law-abiding citizens of the country he wants to run. Not terrorists, not illegal immigrants, not criminals. Just plain ol' Americans, who work and eat and pay taxes, who haven't done anybody any harm and whose only offense is exercising the very same rights that Romney himself trumpets in his speech. Those rights belong to EVERYBODY - didn't this guy show up for high school Civics class?? " End of quote.

A little perspective on Mormon Doctrine. Mormons teach that mankind come to earth for a purpose. That purpose is to be tested. Two plans in the pre-mortal existence were presented to Mormon God. One was by Satan who would force everyone to obey God's commandments. The other one was presented by God's first first-born, Jesus, who wanted man to decide and choose for himself whether to follow God and progress (evolve) throughout the eternities, or reject God's laws and be subject to the eternal status quo. God chose to give mankind the freedom to choose for themselves.

From Mitt's perspective, the freedoms that exist in the United States come from God, freedoms that were instituted to allow the restored true gospel of Jesus Christ to be restored in a country that values freedom of religion and tolerance for divergent beliefs. Mitt truly believes this. While what Romney believes is true, his understanding is very limited and compromised.

But, God also gave man the freedom not to believe that. The common historic version of Christianity is not the one Mormons believe and to teach in public education the Christian religion as generally practiced by Americans would be to teach false doctrine from the Mormon perspective.

In what context does religion equate to "humility, love, and open-mindedness"? Freedom requires religion?" Maybe in Saudi Arabia or Talibanistan, where nonbelievers are publicly executed. "Secularism is a religion?" Anyone who would say that doesn't know the difference between philosophy and religion, and is incapable of successfully practicing either.

When an obviously intelligent presidential candidate has to abase himself to win the support of religionists in order to secure the nomination of a major American political party, at least one segment of this country is in need of correcting its course, and it's up to the rest of us to put forth the means or correction. Romney's speech was an example of the tail wagging the elephant."

It is religion and morality alone which can establish the principles upon which freedom can securely stand. The only foundation of a free constitution is pure virtue. --John Adams

We have no government armed with power capable of contending with human passions unbridled by morality and religion. . . . Our constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other. -- John Adams

Our liberty depends on our education, our laws, and habits . . . it is founded on morals and religion, whose authority reigns in the heart, and on the influence all these produce on public opinion before that opinion governs rulers. -- Fisher Ames, the man who actually drafted the First Amendment, not Thomas Jefferson, who wasn't even in the country when the Constitution was written.

Without morals a republic cannot subsist any length of time; they therefore who are decrying the Christian religion, whose morality is so sublime & pure, [and] which denounces against the wicked eternal misery, and [which] insured to the good eternal happiness, are undermining the solid foundation of morals, the best security for the duration of free governments. --Charles Carroll, signer of the Declaration of Independence.

The only foundation for a useful education in a republic is to be laid in religion. Without this there can be no virtue, and without virtue there can be no liberty, and liberty is the object and life of all republican governments. --Benjamin Rush, signer of the Declaration of Independence.

Indeed, the right of a society or government to [participate] in matters of religion will hardly be contested by any persons who believe that piety, religion, and morality are intimately connected with the well being of the state and indispensable to the administrations of civil justice. --Joseph Storey, Supreme Court justice

There's way more of the same for anyone who's actually interested in the facts. What Romney said today would be considered mealy-mouthed to our Founders.

Treaty of Tripoli?

Article 11 reads: "As the Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion; as it has in itself no character of enmity against the laws, religion, or tranquillity, of Mussulmen; and, as the said States never entered into any war, or act of hostility against any Mahometan nation, it is declared by the parties, that no pretext arising from religious opinions, shall ever produce an interruption of the harmony existing between the two countries." John Adams approved and signed it.

"The central reason why religion cannot be open minded - it teaches that there is one universal truth and it has the answers. Science, on the other hand, teaches that we don't have the answers, most of the stuff we think we know is wrong, and that until we can prove something we should be very careful of actually accepting it as fact.

Atheism is not a denial of the gods, it is a denial of our belief in the gods. Should the evidence mount up going against our basic assumption of there being no gods, our beliefs will mostly shift accordingly (Though whether we follow those gods is another question entirely.)

Now atheists are generally fearful because there are various christianists out there who seem to think atheism equals immorality when the only movement I can think of seriously dedicated to bringing about the end of the world I can think of - the Rapturist movement - is, in fact, religious.

The Bible does not tell us to not engage in slavery, it does not tell us to not engage in torture, it does not tell us to treat other races as equals.

Nor are people who aren't Christians less moral (Just look up some jail statistics for example.) This is not to say that Christians are less moral than atheists, but rather simply that we are not moral people because someone up there decided to tell us to be moral. We are moral because we have advanced towards empathy, towards caring about each other and have started to look beyond established beliefs to find our moral mores.

In the face of Romney's statments, let's make it tougher:

Let's say something like "We live in a pluralistic society where a wall has been built between church and state in order to protect all of us from the imposition of religion. We do not need to follow a particular creed or to even be religious or even believe in God to be full citizens."

Candidates should proclaim loud and clear about the values that inform our democracy -- among them the freedom to worship as we will but also freedom from the rule of religion in our lives. Our seminal documents speak to this. This is who we are as a nation. Anyone who says that the wall does not exist or that the wall should be brought down, who conflates freedom and religious belief, does not get it.

On the other hand, maybe we should all be asking (again and once more) why the candidates are even talking about personal religious beliefs in the first place as a measure of their suitability for office. This is serious stuff with serious long-term consequences to our collective freedoms.

There are still a number of other religions that are NOT covered by this "acceptance" in the public sphere in this country. And my point is, if you can't expressly ACCEPT and WELCOME all of them, then you shouldn't be expressly accepting and welcoming only SOME of them.


"Freedom is not lost by a sudden thrust in the dark of the night, but by single imperceptable digits, one at a time...." Roy O. McClain, Pastor First Baptist Church, Atlanta, in a seminar in 1958.

About Me

Have been working on Pardue Genealogy for many years. Genealogy is always a work in progress!